Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

8 Best Just Food For Dogs Alternatives in 2024: Reviews & Top Picks

Written by: Rachel Giordano

Last Updated on April 13, 2024 by Dogster Team

8 Best Just Food For Dogs Alternatives in 2024: Reviews & Top Picks


Dr. Paola Cuevas Photo


Dr. Paola Cuevas

Veterinarian, MVZ

The information is current and up-to-date in accordance with the latest veterinarian research.

Learn more »

Dog eating Nom Nom Fresh Dog FoodFresh dog food delivery services have crashed into the pet industry like a tidal wave, and with good reason. If you are a pet owner, odds are that you have contemplated feeding your beloved pets these human-grade foods; perhaps you already do! There are many fresh pet food services out there, one being Just Food For Dogs, but they are just one of many.

Many factors can influence which fresh dog delivery service to go with, and weighing the pros and cons helps considerably. For example, Just Food For Dogs does not offer free shipping like other companies, but they do offer recipes for cats, as some people may want to use a service that offers food for all of their fur babies. It could also be the price that has you pausing on this brand, as human-grade pet food is certainly not cheap compared to traditional options. Whatever your reason, we’re listing our reviews of the top eight Just Food For Dogs alternatives to help you weed through the many questions you may have.

Dogster_Website dividers_v1_Jan 18 2024-01-TESTA Glimpse at Our Favorites in 2024

Rating Image Product Details
Open Farm Open Farm
  • Wide variety of recipes and products
  • High protein recipes
  • Ethically sourced ingredients
  • Second place
    Nom Nom Nom Nom
  • High-protein, human-grade ingredients
  • Discount for multiple dogs
  • Free shipping
  • The 8 Just Food for Dogs Alternatives

    1. Open Farm Pork & Ancient Grains vs Just Food For Dogs Beef & Russet Potato

    Open Farm vs Just for Dogs

    Open Farm has a wide variety of high-protein recipes for both dogs and cats. Every single ingredient can be traced back to its origin; you can even enter the bar code or the name of a certain recipe to trace every ingredient in that particular dish. They only source from farms that practice humane and ethical standards, and they work with certified partners to ensure all recipes meet high-quality values.

    All protein used in their recipes comes from 100% humanely raised sources without antibiotics, and all fish is wild-caught. You also will not find any fillers or artificial flavors. Their recipes offer chicken, beef, venison, turkey, and fish. They also offer dehydrated treats, bone broths, and goat milk.

    Open Farm can be costly, especially if you have multiple pets, but they do offer a 10% discount when you sign up for their services. You’ll also receive free shipping on orders over $50 in the continental U.S. With the 100% human-grade ingredients, the many recipes to choose from, and the tracing options, we feel Open Farm is a good Just Food For Dogs alternative.

    2. The Farmer’s Dog Beef Recipe vs Just Food For Dogs Beef & Russet Potato

    The Farmer's Dog vs Just for Dogs

    The Farmer’s Dog costs roughly $2 per day, but you’ll need to consider all of the different variables about your dog to get an accurate cost. Their food is made with human-grade ingredients, and all meals are pre-portioned depending on the breed, age, weight, etc. They offer a 20% discount when you sign up, and they always offer free shipping. You can pause, cancel, or reactivate your subscription at any time.

    All food is prepared in USDA kitchens and formulated by Certified Board Veterinary Nutritionists. All the recipes also meet AFFCO’s standards. To get started, you’ll be prompted to answer questions about your dog, but this is standard for most fresh dog food delivery services. You’ll probably need to adjust deliveries, as you may run out of freezer and fridge room if you get too much at once.

    Just Food For Dogs is available through reputable dog retailer companies, making it slightly more accessible than The Farmer’s Dog.

    3. Spot and Tango Beef & Millet vs Just Food For Dogs Beef & Russet Potato


    Spot and Tango are unique in that they offer dry kibble in addition to fresh food for dogs, but that doesn’t mean the dry kibble isn’t just as healthy. All recipes are free from artificial flavors, fillers, and preservatives, and a team of vets prepares and specially formulates all recipes, so you’ll know your pup is getting the best of the best with human-grade ingredients.

    Different variables determine just how much Spot and Tango’s plan will cost you. In general, it costs $1 per day to feed the dry kibble and $2 per day for the fresh food. To get an accurate cost, you’ll need to provide information about your dog so that they can formulate a meal plan. Meal plans are based on your dog’s weight, age, activity level, and more. After you provide the information, they will customize a meal plan suitable for your dog’s needs. The meals also come pre-portioned, which is a nice perk.

    Spot and Tango is pricey, but they do offer 20% off at checkout, a 100% money-back guarantee, and free shipping. They also offer a “50% off for life” promo on snacks when you sign up for their subscription services.

    Although Spot and Tango has a lot to offer, you must complete a lengthy form before choosing a meal plan, and discounts are only applied to certain items when you sign up for a subscription.

    4. Ollie Turkey Recipe vs Just Food For Dogs Chicken & White Rice

    Ollie vs Just for Dogs

    Ollie offers recipes made from human-grade meat that consists of beef, lamb, turkey, or chicken. All recipes meet AAFCO’s nutrition standards, and all ingredients are carefully sourced through trusted suppliers. Ollie operates the same way as other fresh dog food delivery services in that you take a quiz to provide information about your dog, and they customize a plan depending on your dog’s needs. The meals come pre-portioned, but the cost will vary depending on your pup’s weight, age, and any special needs or considerations.

    You can customize your subscription to work for you, such as delivery dates and portions. Ollie, however, does not offer samples; it is a subscription-based plan only. They also do not offer recipes for feline friends.

    5. Nom Nom Chicken Cuisine vs Just Food For Dogs Chicken & White Rice

    Nom Nom vs Just for Dogs

    Nom Nom is a well-known fresh dog food delivery service that offers high-protein dog foods made from human-grade ingredients. A pleasing feature is they offer pre-portioned packages, taking the guesswork out of how much to feed, unlike Just Food For Dogs. Their recipes are formulated by Board Certified Veterinary Nutritionists, and the ingredients are never outsourced to third parties. All recipes also meet AAFCO’s level of nutrition. To get started, you’ll fill out some information on your dog so that they can formulate a meal plan. A downside is that they do not offer any treats.

    Subscribing to a fresh dog food delivery service can be pricey, but Nom Nom offers certain incentives that help keep the cost down. For example, they offer a discount if you have multiple dogs. They also provide samples of their recipes without having to sign up for a subscription. Another perk is they offer free shipping, and you’ll enjoy a 20% discount for the first 2 weeks of signing up.

    With the pre-portioned recipes, the many discounts, and the nutritional value of the food, Nom Nom is one of the better Just Food For Dogs alternatives.

    6. PetPlate Barkin’ Beef vs Just Food For Dogs Beef & Russet Potato

    PetPlate vs Just for Dogs

    When you use a subscription fresh dog food delivery service, you may run into the problem of not having enough freezer space to store the food. PetPlate, however, packages their food differently: it comes in smaller containers. All meals are pre-portioned based on the information you provide about your dog. All recipes (might we add the names of the recipes are adorable) are formulated by a veterinarian nutritionist and prepared in USDA kitchens. All meals are hot-filled to ensure safety and then flash-frozen to ensure all ingredients stay fresh.

    PetPlate operates just like the others except for one unique feature: they offer gift cards. They offer amounts from $50 to $250, and you can send them to someone else or even yourself! They also make organic treats and supplements, such as chicken apple sausage bites and cookies. As far as cost, an average meal for small pups runs around $2.85 daily; the bigger the dog, the bigger the bill, but they offer free shipping on all orders. This is a subscription-only delivery service.

    While the smaller prepacked containers might benefit some dog owners, other may find this feature wasteful and bulky. Just Food For Dogs packages may be bigger, but they are compact and can offer multiple meals per package depending on your dog.

    7. A Pup Above Turkey Pawella Recipe vs Just Food For Dogs Chicken & White Rice

    A Pup Above vs Just for Dogs

    A Pup Above offers exceptional nutrition for dogs, but their method for doing so is a little different. They use a sous-vide cooking method, meaning the food is cooked slowly and evenly to retain all the nutrients. All food is prepared in USDA kitchens and is 100% human-grade. As far as protein, A Pup Above beats the competition, offering 11-grams per serving.  They also offer sampler packs of their recipes without having to subscribe. All recipes have quality ingredients, such as non-GMO veggies and superfoods.

    They only offer free shipping when you order three bags or more of food, and they only offer a money-back guarantee on the first order. They also do not offer treats or supplements.

    8. Evermore Pet Food Beef Recipe vs Just Food For Dogs Beef & Russet Potato

    Evermore vs Just for Dogs

    Evermore Pet Food uses the sous-vide cooking method, so the food is gently cooked to lock in all of the organic nutrients inside a vacuum-sealed bag. You can shop online or buy in stores if you happen to live where buying in-store is an option. All food is cooked in USDA kitchens, and all ingredients are grown from trusted U.S.A. sources. The packages are not stored in large bags, so storing them until you need them is easier and saves you room. They also offer grain-free recipes for dogs with allergies.

    They offer free shipping on every order with an additional 5% off a large case if you subscribe; however, you can buy this food without having to subscribe. This food is expensive, but gift cards are available.

    Dogster_Website dividers_v1_Jan 18 2024-03

    Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Right Just Food for Dogs Alternative

    We’ve listed our picks for the top alternatives to Just Food For Dogs human-grade dog chow, but to help you further, here are a few things to consider when shopping around.

    Sensitive Stomachs

    Even though all of our picks make their food with human-grade ingredients, that doesn’t mean your pup won’t have food allergies or  sensitivity issues. If this is something you’re concerned about, you can always inform the company, and they can try and formulate a plan that’s just right for your pooch. It’s a good idea to make sure the fresh dog food delivery service you choose has the option to return the food with a refund if your pup can’t tolerate it, which most have this option.

    Customized Options

    When you sign up for any fresh dog food, you’ll have to enter information about your dog. This is a standard formality so that the company can formulate a meal plan based on the information you provide. Check to see how their meals are sent and packaged. Sometimes, you can receive too much food, making you run out of room in your freezer. If you’re getting too much at once, make sure you can customize your deliveries to accommodate your needs.


    Your budget plays a huge factor in deciding which company to choose. Feeding fresh dog food means paying a higher price than buying commercial dog food. However, many of these fresh dog food companies offer discounts and free shipping. Unfortunately, to get an accurate amount, you’ll have to go through the process of entering your dog’s information and get a customized plan; only then will you know if it fits into your budget.

    Dogster_Website dividers_v1_Jan 18 2024-01-TEST

    Wrapping Up

    For the top Just Food For Dogs alternatives, Open Farms is a good option because they offer 100% human-grade recipes, treats, bone broths, supplements, and you can trace each ingredient back to its origin. Nom-Nom also offers 100% human-grade recipes, probiotics, and pre-portioned meals, but is a great alternative to Just Food For Dogs because you can receive discounts for multiple dogs and sample packs of all recipes without having to subscribe.

    We hope you’ve enjoyed our reviews of the best Just Food For Dogs alternatives, and we wish you and your beloved canine luck in your search!

    Get Dogster in your inbox!

    Stay informed! Get tips and exclusive deals.
    Dogster Editors Choice Badge
    Shopping Cart


    © Pangolia Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved.