Get

In Your Inbox

Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Should I Avoid Purebred Dogs in Rare Colors? Vet-Approved Facts & FAQ

merle australian shepher dog playing outdoor

Purebred dogs come in more and more colors, but should you avoid buying them? It depends. Rare colors in dogs are linked to genes that can be associated with certain health problems. Some purebred dogs in rare colors are sometimes born with health conditions, such as impaired hearing, ocular defects that can cause blindness, or skin and coat problems.

So, the answer is yes and no, as not all purebred dogs in rare colors come with health issues, but some do. In some cases, rare colors are rare for good reason.

dogster face divider

Why Are Rare Colors Popular?

Like any other market, in the pet trade, rare or unique animals typically command higher prices. They can be a status symbol or hot trend, especially if it’s well known that they’re expensive, and irresponsible breeders will scramble to try to produce these rare specimens to cash in—regardless of potential health problems.

Unfortunately, that can often mean introducing defective genes into the gene pool and producing puppies that are likely to have health problems. This goes for many exaggerated or novel features, including rare coat colors or patterns.

american staffordshire terrier on the grass
Image Credit: Vera Zinkova, Shutterstock

Is Breeding for Rare Colors Unethical?

Breed registries like the American Kennel Club have breed standards for a reason. Some of them are based on aptitude, conformation, and temperament for the dog’s purpose, others are within the confines of the breed’s natural colors or markings and for aesthetic reasons.

Puppies can be born with a range of colors and patterns, even within a responsible breeding program. Color is a low priority after selecting dogs for their health, temperament, and capabilities. With the rare colors, however, irresponsible breeders may prioritize producing certain colors, even if it means pairing unhealthy dogs.

In addition, breeders may produce litter after litter in hopes of getting a rare, high-dollar litter. With shelters filled and more pets than homes to take them in, it’s irresponsible to produce more dogs that don’t contribute positively to the breed.

What Colors Have Health Problems?

Here are some colors that have known health issues as stated from the ASPCA:

Merle

The merle or dapple pattern is an inherited pattern with light and dark pigments, often with blue eyes or pink noses and paw pads on dark dogs. This is typically seen in Australian Shepherds, Dachshunds, and Great Danes, but it’s popping up more and more in other breeds like French Bulldogs and Corgis.

Merle patterns can happen when a dog with the merle gene mates with a dog without the merle gene, or from mating two merle dogs. The puppies from two merle parents, called double-merle, are often born blind or deaf. In fact, mating between two merles is not allowed by kennel clubs since there is a 25% probability of producing puppies with health issues.

merle cardigan welsh corgi dog sitting outdoor
Image Credit: Elisabeth Abramova, Shutterstock

Blue and Lilac

Blue and lilac coats are associated with a color-dilution gene. Diluted black produces a blue coat color and diluted brown creates a lilac coat color. This is common in a lot of “designer” dog breeds and some purebred dogs, including the Kerry Blue Terrier, Australian Cattle Dog, and Boston Terrier.

In some cases, blue or lilac colors are associated with a disease called color dilution alopecia. The puppies might be born with normal coat textures for the breed, but soon, their coat turns dry, dull, and thin, and they show marked reduced hair density between 3 and 12 months of age. They’re left with exposed patches of skin that would normally have hair for protection, but because they don’t, they can have skin issues in those areas.

Image Credit: Susan McQuade, Shutterstock

Will My Merle or Blue Dog Be Sick?

Not necessarily. These dogs may grow up to be healthy and escape the concerns surrounding their genetics.

The issue is larger than just your pup, however. Supporting a breeder who purposely prioritizes a rare or unique color to make a steep profit, rather than breeding to produce the best possible specimens of a breed in terms of health, conformation, and temperament, isn’t a breeder that should be supported. Every breeder has a responsibility to ensure their dogs live a happy, healthy life.

dogster face divider

Conclusion

Rare or unique dog colors and patterns can be part of a purebred dog’s standards. Unfortunately, these colors and patterns may come with health problems, which can be exacerbated by irresponsible breeding with the goal of producing rare and expensive puppies.

You don’t necessarily need to avoid any rare color like merle or blue but do your due diligence. Check into the color standards for your preferred breed and the genetic health concerns associated with them. You should also vet the breeder and make sure that they’re complying with local regulations, conducting genetic testing, and caring for their animals properly.


Featured Image Credit: Christian Kohlhausen, Shutterstock

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Dogster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

Can Dogs Read Our Facial Expressions? What Science Says

Dogs can focus on various aspects of communication beyond verbal ones, similar to humans. For example, we utilize facial expressions when communicating with...

How to Teach Your Dog Recall: A Vet-Approved Training Guide

A reliable recall is among the most crucial skills a dog can learn and one of the most liberating commands their owner can...

Red Merle Australian Shepherd: Info, Pictures, Origin & History

Australian Shepherds are incredibly popular thanks to their beauty, intelligence, and vibrant personalities. The Australian Shepherd’s coat is one of their most eye-catching...

Are Dogs Allowed on the NYC Subway? Guidelines & Exceptions

Traveling throughout New York City is more convenient and cost-effective with the help of the city’s subway system. For just around $2, you...

More related

Can Dogs Have Asthma? Vet-Verified Signs, Diagnosis & Treatment

According to the CDC, nearly 25 million Americans have asthma.1 Symptoms of this respiratory condition include wheezing, coughing, and shortness of breath due...

Rottaf (Rottweiler & Afghan Hound Mix): Info, Pictures, Care & More

The Rottaf is a mixed breed dog produced when you put a Rottweiler and an Afghan Hound together. As you might imagine, this...

That’s My Bed! Poppy and I Go Head-to-Head

Hi, I’m Dr. Karyn! Read my introduction to learn more about me and my five funny dogs, Poppy, Bailey, Kodah, Ned, and Fred....

Why Does My Dog Have Small Bald Spots? Vet Reviewed Signs & Causes

My seven-month-old black Lab has small bald spots on her face, head and a few on her legs. I was wondering what they...

Keep reading

10 Best Blue Buffalo Dog Foods in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

These days, it’s pretty easy to know that your dog’s diet is one of the primary deciding factors in overall lifelong health. We recently had the opportunity to review all of Blue Buffalo’s recipe lines to see what they offer...

dog eating dog food

Homemade Dog Food vs Store-Bought: Vet-Verified Pros & Cons

Dog owners want to give their dogs the best food possible, which may lead some people to wonder which is better for them: homemade or store-bought food? In this article, we compare both in detail. In almost all aspects, store-bought...

Dogster_Homemade vs Store-bought dogfood

Can Dogs Eat Sage? Vet Approved Facts & FAQ

Sage is a commonly used herb in the kitchen that flavors foods and is also used in essential oils, creams, ointments, and medicines. If you cook with sage or have it growing abundantly in your garden, you may wonder if...

Can Dogs Eat Sage

Can Dogs Eat Honeydew Melon? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts & FAQ

Honeydew melon is a favorite treat to eat in the summer heat. But if your dog is trying to get a piece, you want to make sure it is safe. Can dogs eat honeydew? Yes, dogs can eat honeydew in...

Can Dogs Eat Honeydew Melon

Can Dogs Eat Dried Apricots? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts & Info

Our dogs are omnivorous creatures—just like us. That means they could enjoy a wide selection of meat, fruits, veggies, and grains! If you’ve been looking for a few different options, other than boring dog treats to get your dog’s appetite...

Dogster-Can-Dogs-Eat-Dried Apricot

Can Dogs Eat Crackers? Vet-Reviewed Facts & FAQ

How great are crackers? Slathered with dip, layered with cheese, or eaten just on their own, they are simple yet delicious snacks. But is that the case for dogs? Most of us are probably aware that our dogs will happily...

Can Dogs Eat Crackers

Can Dogs Eat Calamari? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts & Risks

Calamari is an Italian word for squid, which is exactly what calamari is. You can find calamari in most seafood restaurants, and it’s a favorite among many seafood lovers. If you bring your pooch to a seafood restaurant that allows...

Can Dogs Eat_calamari

Can Dogs Eat Pork? Vet-Approved Nutrition Facts & FAQ

There is always a time for pork, whether it’s crispy bacon to accompany your waffles, pork sausages for lunch, or a pork roast with all the trimmings for a special occasion. There are many opportunities where pork can get your...

Can Dogs Eat Pork