Get

In Your Inbox

Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

How to Make Your Dog Love Their New Toy: 5 Great Ways

owner using dog toy to play with his pet

You might notice you’ve bought your dog plenty of new toys, but they just don’t seem interested. They might run over to the fancy ball, sniff it once, and walk away. Is it something you’re doing wrong, or do you have a low-energy dog? There could be a few reasons for their behavior, but you can try encouraging them to pay more attention to their toys.

Continue reading to learn how to make your dog love their new toy.

divider single dog paw oct 2024

The 5 Ways to Make Your Dog Fall in Love With Their New Toy

1. Fill It with Treats

Image By: anetapics, Shutterstock

One surefire way to get your dog more interested in their new toy is to fill it with their favorite treats. If they seem interested in their Kong but don’t stick around long enough, try filling it with peanut butter or their favorite treats! When dogs see that they get something yummy from playing with their toys, they are more incentivized to use them. There are many toys to choose from, like treat dispenser balls and pet puzzles.

Pros
  • Great way to give treats
  • Reusable
  • Long-lasting
Cons
  • Messy cleanup
  • Could overeat

2. Get Excited

Another great way to get your dog excited about their toys is for you to be excited! When you buy them a new toy, introduce it to them with excitement to show that it’s something positive. Present it as a great new activity for you and the dog rather than throw it in with the rest of their toys.

Bring the toy in with a smile on your face, wave it around in front of them a few times, and show them that it’s a new present for them.

Pros
  • Fun for you
  • Better engagement
  • Positive reinforcement
Cons
  • Can spoil your dog
  • Can teach bad behaviors (i.e., coming home = new toy)

3. Interact with Them

Dog playing with his fleece toy
Image By: Josh Sorenson, Pexels

Interacting with your dog and their new toy can encourage them to play with it. You can interact with your dog by bringing a new rope toy out in the backyard and playing tug of war. Or play fetch with their ball after letting them sniff it and getting acquainted quickly. Show them this is a fun way to play with you and a positive way to bond and build your relationship.

Pros
  • Builds relationship
  • Interactive play
Cons
  • Could build on bad behavior

4. Use It as a Reward

A great way to get your dog to love their new toy is to present it to them as a reward. You can bring in your toy and hide it for a while rather than give it to them right away. Wait until they listen to a command or use it in training, then give it to them. You can use a toy that dispenses treats, so they recognize it as something they get when they’ve been a good dog.

Pros
Cons
  • Might be expected

5. Find the Right One

white dog playing puzzle toy
Image By: Lenti Hill, Shutterstock

Sometimes, when it comes to new toys, your dog might not love them right away because they aren’t appealing or fun. It can take trial and error to find what suits your dog’s play style, personality, or energy level. For example, if you have a dog with an aggressive personality who chews on your shoes, getting them a chew toy might counteract your intentions. Try turning to something that will positively reroute their behavior.

Pros
  • Supports good behavior
  • Helps to find a lifelong favorite
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Time-consuming

divider dog paws 2 oct 2024

Conclusion

Finding a way to get your dog to love their new toys can be a lengthy process. Whether they seem to turn their nose (or snout) up to the expensive, high-end, and highly rated toys or seem to destroy some too easily, their reaction depends on the toy you select and how you give it to them.

Be patient with your dog and try not to force toys on them or throw them in a pile with the rest. Learn their behavior patterns to determine which toy will work best for them.

Related Read:


Featured Image Credit: Alena Veasey, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything dog

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Dogster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

False Dog Pregnancy: Signs, Causes & Care (Vet Answer)

What do you do if your dog goes into heat, comes out of it, was safe at home the entire time, and then...

Are Labradors Smart Dogs? Canine Intelligence Explained

The Labrador Retriever, more commonly known as a “Lab,” is one of the most popular dogs worldwide, especially among families. This working breed...

10 Best Dog Foods for Terrier Mixes in 2025: Reviews & Top Picks

Are you searching for the perfect food for your Terrier mix and feel lost in the sea of available dog foods? You are...

Can Dogs Eat Mochi? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts & Risks

Dogs don’t stop to think about whether or not they should eat something, so it’s up to us as dog owners to do...

More related

Top 4 Dog-Friendly Beaches in Sanibel, FL 2025: Off-Leash & On-Leash Places to Go

Sanibel is a surprisingly dog-friendly area. The island doesn’t allow dogs everywhere, but many dog-friendly attractions exist. Therefore, it is a suitable spot...

160 Popular & Unique German Wirehaired Pointer Names

German Wirehaired pointers are so unique in appearance and personality, and it’s only fitting that you give them a name that reflects that....

Why Does My Dog Have Scabs on Their Back? 6 Vet-Verified Reasons

Finding crusty scabs on your dog’s back can be stressful for pet owners. Not only are scabs gross to touch and clean, but...

How to Trim Puppy Nails: Vet-Approved Step-by-Step Guide

Trimming your puppy’s nails is an essential part of their grooming routine. However, many puppies find this process uncomfortable or frightening. To ensure...

Keep reading

Natural Balance Dog Food Review 2025: Recalls, Pros & Cons

Review Summary Natural Balance is a brand of dog food that was first created in Burbank in California back in 1989 by Dick Van Patten. This company aims to produce high-quality pet foods that meet your dogs’ nutritional requirements and...

Dogster_Natural Balance Dog Food Review

How to Keep Birds Away from Dog Food: 7 Easy & Effective Ideas

If you are someone that feeds your dog outdoors, you are bound to have some trouble with the local wildlife scavenging for their share. Birds are intelligent creatures that are built for survival. When they pick up on an easy...

adorable border collie dog drinking from a water bowl

Why Does My Dog Play With Their Food? 4 Reasons & What to Do

Finding more kibble littered around your house than in your dog’s bowl (or their belly) can leave many dog parents wondering why their dog prefers to toss, chase, bat, or even roll their food around rather than eat it. Playtime...

Australian husky tipped dog food container

7 Best Dog Foods for West Highland White Terriers in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

The West Highland Terrier is a breed of dog beloved by many. If you’re lucky enough to be a pet parent to one of these pups, you know just how quirky they can be. You also know just how important...

West Highland White Terrier dog on green grass

Can Dogs Eat Popcorn? Vet-Reviewed Health & Safety Guide

I’m not a big popcorn lover, but my daughter is. And so is my dog Tula, based on the longing look in her eyes and the trail of slobber that escapes her mouth. My daughter is better trained than the...

Can Dogs Eat Popcorn

Which Nuts Are Bad for Dogs? Vet-Reviewed Safe & Toxic Options

Keeping our animals healthy is a top concern for us pet owners, and the foods that they eat often present the biggest danger. For example, many people worry about nuts because there are several kinds, and some are safe for...

a bowl of assorted nuts

American Journey vs Taste of the Wild Dog Food: Our 2025 In-Depth Comparison

Choosing the right dog food is a hard decision for a pet owner. You want to provide your pup with the best food possible and hope that whatever brand you choose doesn’t do too much damage to your budget. But...

Dogster_Dog Food American Journey VS Taste of the Wild

Can Dogs Eat Corn? Vet-Reviewed Facts & Nutritional Benefits

Corn is a ubiquitous ingredient that shows up in all sorts of things, including dog food. This makes many people believe that corn is completely safe for dogs. So, can dogs eat corn? Corn is safe for dogs as long...

Can Dogs Eat Corn