Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

6 Best Spot and Tango Dog Food Alternatives in 2024: Reviews & Top Picks

Written by: Patricia Dickson

Last Updated on July 4, 2024 by Dogster Team

Italian Greyhound dog eating from bowl at home

6 Best Spot and Tango Dog Food Alternatives in 2024: Reviews & Top Picks


Dr. Paola Cuevas Photo


Dr. Paola Cuevas

Veterinarian, MVZ

The information is current and up-to-date in accordance with the latest veterinarian research.

Learn more »

Italian Greyhound dog eating from bowl at home

When you have a dog, you want only the best for them, from their healthcare to their food. Fresh food subscription services offer some of the best nutrition available for your pooch and, as such, are becoming more and more popular.

However, there are so many fresh food subscription services today that choosing one can get overwhelming. Spot and Tango are some of the leading fresh dog food companies, but their food or service may not work for your dog. Luckily, there are other options out there.

We will review our top six choices below and outline some benefits of feeding your dogs fresh food. Let’s dive in!

Dogster divider_v3_NEW_MAY_24_

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2024

Rating Image Product Details
Nom-Nom Now Nom-Nom Now
  • Free delivery
  • USDA-approved
  • Personalized, single-serve meals
  • Second place
    Open Farm Open Farm
  • Eco-friendly
  • Wide variety
  • Ethically sourced
  • Third place
    Ollie Ollie
  • Handpicked ingredients
  • No fillers or artificial flavorings
  • Food catered to your dog’s needs
  • The 6 Best Spot and Tango Dog Food Alternatives

    1. Nom-Nom Fresh Dog Food Beef Mash vs Spot and Tango Fresh Dog Food Beef & Millet


    One of our favorite Spot and Tango dog food alternatives goes to Nom-Nom. The food is human-grade and USDA-approved for added taste, flavor, and good health. You can skip or cancel anytime, and the meals are personalized to fit your dog’s size and needs. The meals are single-serve, and the site features free delivery in 48 states.

    The only drawback we found to Nom-Nom Now is that they automatically bill your account every month, and the food takes up quite a bit of freezer and fridge space, which isn’t ideal if you have limited space.

    2. Open Farm Dog Food Wild-Caught Salmon & Ancient Grains vs Spot and Tango Dog Food Cod & Salmon Unkibble


    A great Spot and Tango dog food alternative for the money is Open Farm. The food is affordable, ethically sourced, and has a wide variety of proteins and flavors. The food is advertised as human-grade, which is an informative term, but this is not legally regulated, and the site also allows subscription and one-time orders, unlike other options on the list.

    The company also offers excellent customer service. The only drawbacks seem to be the open fresh food taking up the fridge and freezer room and the fact that some pets didn’t like the taste of the fresh food. All in all, for the money, we feel this is a perfect Spot and Tango alternative.

    We gave the win to Open Farm – their range of products is comparable to Spot and Tango’s, in addition to an impressive and affordable cost.

    • Open Farm Wild-Caught Salmon & Ancient Grains

    3. Ollie Pet Food Fresh Dog Food Fresh Lamb vs Spot and Tango Lamb and Brown Rice


    A premium option is Ollie Pet Food. It’s a bit more expensive than other options, but the food is catered to your dog’s needs. In addition, they have a two-week auto-delivery system, though some customers don’t like the idea of the bill coming out of their accounts automatically. However, since all the ingredients are handpicked, and the food contains no fillers or artificial flavorings, we feel it is a great alternative if you can work it into your budget.

    There have been reports of the food causing stomach issues in some dogs, and thawing the food can be tough, especially when your dog is waiting and licking their lips!

    4. The Farmer’s Dog Fresh Food Turkey Recipe vs Spot Dog Food and Tango Turkey & Red Quinoa


    Number four on our list goes to The Farmer’s Dog. The site offers a two-week trial, and all their dog food is made in a USDA-approved kitchen. In addition, the packages for their dog food are biodegradable and recyclable, which means not only will you be feeding your dog healthy, tasty food, but you’ll also be doing your part to help the environment. The food is made with fish oil and added vitamins for extra health benefits.

    However, the food can end up being a little expensive for larger dog breeds, and it does take up freezer and fridge space. Still, the packaging makes this fresh dog food delivery service worth checking out.

    Both provide exceptional nutrition when it comes to fresh food options.

    5. PetPlate Fresh Dog Food Barkin’ Beef vs Spot and Tango Dog Food Beef & Millet


    PetPlate offers pre-portioned meals for your pet with no preservatives or fillers added. It also features fish oil and vitamins for added health benefits. The food is advertised as human-grade but can get quite expensive for larger breed dogs and is not ideal for pet parents on a budget. Also, it requires freezer and fridge space for four weeks of food, which can be tough for someone who doesn’t have much room.

    If you have a smaller breed dog, it’s probably an excellent choice for you, but it is one of the more expensive foods on our list compared to others.

    6. Stay Fresh Dog Food Subscription Service Beef Recipe vs Spot and Tango Dog Food Beef Recipe


    Last but not least on our list is Stay dog food. This site offers a 100% guarantee for 30 days if you’re unsatisfied. The food is manufactured with a focus on digestive health, with the site even offering free fecal tests for digestive health for your dog. Like many subscription services, the cost of this food varies according to the breed size. It does require freezer space and has automatic billing, which some customers don’t like, and a few customers reported their dogs not eating it because they didn’t like the taste.

    However, if you’re looking for a food you can try and still get your money back if it doesn’t suit your dog, this is the one to try.

    Dogster divider_v3_NEW_MAY_24_

    Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Best Spot and Tango Dog Food Alternatives

    Now that you know what we think the best Spot and Tango fresh dog food alternatives are, you might wonder why you should go through all the trouble of signing your dog up to receive fresh food. After all, isn’t dry dog food supposed to be packed full of protein, vitamins, and minerals?

    In this guide, we’ll give you a few of the top benefits of feeding your dog fresh food.

    Helps with a Healthy Weight

    Commercial food is heavy in starches, which can lead to obesity in your dog if you’re not careful. On the other hand, fresh dog food contains lightly cooked ingredients, such as kale, turkey, lamb, sweet potatoes, and organ meats.

    Fresh foods skip the fillers and preservatives that are bad for your pet in favor of healthy proteins and veggies.

    dog eating from bowl in kitchen
    Image Credit: Pixel-Shot, Shutterstock

    Helps Prevent Medical Conditions

    Just as with humans, eating food rich in antioxidants and high levels of healthy protein can ward off sickness and some diseases. Unfortunately, many commercial dog foods contain very low-quality ingredients that don’t do anything to help your pet’s immune system function properly.

    Helps Develop a Shiny Coat

    Fresh food also helps with shiny coat development. No one wants their dog’s fur to be dull and lackluster. Fresh food contains all the ingredients needed to keep your dog’s coat shiny, full, and healthy.

    Dogster divider_v3_NEW_MAY_24_


    This concludes our guide on the best Spot and Tango dog food alternatives for 2023. Our top choice went to Nom-Nom Now for their personalized meals that are made to fit any dog’s needs. Our second spot went to Open Farm for its affordable, eco-friendly dog food. Finally, our premium pick went to Ollie Pet Food for their handpicked ingredients and overall good customer service.

    We hope our reviews and buying guide will help you choose the best dog food for your pet, along with a dog food subscription service you love.

    Featured Image Credit: New Africa, Shutterstock

    PangoVet Image Speak With A Vet Online

    Get Dogster in your inbox!

    Stay informed! Get tips and exclusive deals.
    Dogster Editors Choice Badge
    Shopping Cart


    © Pangolia Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved.