Heartgard vs. Heartgard Plus: Vet-Verified Differences?

Review Summary

Heartworm is a deadly parasite that can impact dogs just about anywhere in the United States. They are most prevalent in the Southeastern US, but anywhere that has mosquitoes has the potential for heartworm disease. These parasites invade the heart and the vessels of the heart and lungs, potentially leading to permanent damage, heart failure, blood clots, and death.

Keeping your dog on regular heartworm prevention prescriptions from your vet is the best way to protect your dog against these awful parasites. Heartgard and Heartgard Plus are two of the most popular heartworm products on the market, but what’s the difference between them?

At a Glance

Let’s look at the key points of each product.

Overview of Heartgard

Heartgard is a heartworm prevention medication with ivermectin as the primary ingredient. Ivermectin is capable of killing heartworms in their larval stage, preventing them from growing to adulthood in the blood vessels. Heartworms are spread through the bite of mosquitoes, which leave larva (microfilaria) behind in your dog’s blood after the bite. Without passing through a mosquito, a heartworm cannot complete its life cycle. This medication is safe for dogs 6 weeks of age and older, although you should talk to your vet before giving Heartgard to a pregnant dog. It’s necessary to administer this medication as directed every 30 days. Late administration of Heartgard can allow your dog to be unprotected against heartworms. Once the worms pass their larval stage, Heartgard can no longer protect them. Keep in mind that the original Heartgard has been discontinued since September 2020. So most likely your vet will only be offering Heartgard Plus. Unfortunately, we couldn’t find an exact statement from the company as to why they made the change, but we trust it was for good reason and that they’re now offering the best product to pet parents that they can.

Overview of Heartgard Plus

Like Heartgard, Heartgard Plus uses ivermectin as its primary ingredient to protect against heartworm. However, Heartworm Plus also contains pyrantel, which is an antiparasitic medication that is effective against roundworms and hookworms. Roundworms and hookworms are both transmissible to humans. They are transmitted through contact with infected feces or ground or grass where infected feces has been. By administering Heartgard Plus every month, you will protect your dog against heartworms, hookworms, and roundworms. Heartgard Plus is also safe for dogs aged 6 weeks and over. The manufacturer's prescribing leaflet also states that it has a wide margin of safety for pregnant and nursing females. This medication must be administered every 30 days for maximum heartworm protection. Hookworms and roundworms are much easier to treat and are overall less dangerous than heartworms.

What Are the Differences Between Them?

Efficacy Against Heartworms

Edge: Tie

Heartgard and Heartgard Plus use the same doses of ivermectin to protect against heartworms. They are equal in their functionality for killing heartworms in the larval stage.

Efficacy Against Intestinal Parasites

Edge: Heartgard Plus

Out of the two, only Heartgard Plus contains pyrantel, a medication that kills hookworms and roundworms. Because of this, only Heartgard Plus protects against these intestinal parasites.

If you're uncertain about which parasite prevention medication to use, consult a veterinarian for guidance.

If you need to speak with a vet but can't get to one, head over to PangoVet. It's our online service where you can talk to a vet online and get the advice you need for your dog — all at an affordable price!

Availability and Price

Edge: Heartgard Plus

Since the original Heartgard has been discontinued, Heartgard Plus is what you’re most likely to find available and what your vet would prescribe and recommend.

Ease of Use

Edge: Tie

These medications both come in a chewable that most dogs find appetizing and will eat without fuss. Although they’re both extremely easy to administer for most dogs, these medications must be given every 30 days. If given late, then there is an increased risk for your dog to get heartworms.

It is not recommended to offer the first dose without a veterinarian's prescription because the vet needs to check your dog to ensure they are not already infested with adult forms of the heartworm parasite.

What the Users Say

We’ve gone ahead and done research to see what other dog owners have to say about using Heartgard and Heartgard Plus. With Heartgard, they loved the simplicity of the medication and the efficacy against heartworms. For Heartgard Plus, dog owners love the fact that this medication protects against heartworms and some intestinal parasites. Since Heartgard is now discontinued, Heartgard Plus is easier to find in pet pharmacies and vet clinics. Some people note that counterfeit products have ended up on the market, especially with unscrupulous online pharmacies. To keep your dog safe, it’s best to purchase these medications directly from your veterinarian, and that means you’ll be purchasing Heartgard Plus.

Conclusion

When it comes down to it, Heartgard Plus is a better option than Heartgard. It provides greater protection for your dog against parasites, and since hookworms and roundworms can be contagious to humans, it also helps protect you and your family. Of course, regular Heartgard is no longer available since it has been discontinued, so you’ll have to purchase Heartgard Plus from your vet if you’ve always used and trusted this brand, although your vet will be able to provide you with the most suitable of all the options available in the market. Related Read: 

• Can Dogs Overdose on Heartgard? Facts & FAQ (Vet Answer)

• Is Heartgard Safe for Dogs? Vet Approved Facts & FAQ