Click to Skip Ahead
Choosing the right food for your dog should be simple, right? We get it—with countless brands, endless ingredient lists, and ever-evolving advice on what’s best for each dog, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. What’s truly healthy for our furry friends? And what’s just clever marketing? As dog owners, we all want to ensure we’re providing the best nutrition for our companions, but with so many options, the choice can be fairly daunting and (at times) downright confusing.
That’s where we step in. We’ve done the legwork for you and put two popular dog food brands, Kirkland and Blue Buffalo, head-to-head in a detailed comparison. We’ll break down the ingredients, nutritional value, price points, and more to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re looking for the most balanced diet for your active pup or simply the best option for a sensitive stomach, we’ve got you covered.
Ready to discover which brand stands out? Keep reading as we dive into the details of Kirkland and Blue Buffalo, so you can confidently choose the right food for your dog’s health and happiness.
Important note: The information in this article has been fact-checked by one of our in-house veterinarians; however, the opinions and evaluations expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the veterinarian’s perspective. This article is not a substitute for personalized veterinary advice. Any concerns regarding your dog’s nutrition or changes in their diet should be discussed directly with your veterinarian.
Winning Recipes Compared
| Rating | Image | Product | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
Blue Buffalo |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
|
Kirkland |
|
CHECK PRICE |
Brands at a Glance
- Types of food: Puppy, Adult, Senior, Dry Food, Wet Food, Treats.
- Average cost/lbs: $3/lb
- Recipes: Chicken, Beef, Fish, and Lamb, with mixed combinations of Brown Rice, Cranberries, Blueberries, Flaxseed, Potatoes, and Carrots.
- Types of food: Puppy, Adult, Senior, Dry Food, Wet Food, Treats.
- Average cost/lbs: $1.50/lb
- Recipes: Salmon & Sweet Potato, Lamb, Rice & Vegetable, Chicken, Rice & Egg, Beef & Sweet Potato, Turkey & Sweet Potato
About Blue Buffalo Dog Food
Blue Buffalo is a well-known pet food brand, recognized for its commitment to using high-quality, natural ingredients. Founded in 2003 by the Bishop family, Blue Buffalo was inspired by their beloved Airedale Terrier, Blue, who was diagnosed with cancer. Determined to provide him with the best nutrition possible, the Bishops worked with veterinarians and animal nutritionists to develop a line of pet food that focused on natural, high-quality ingredients to support health and longevity, mirroring a diet they would eat in the wild, free from unnecessary fillers and by-products. Blue Buffalo’s mission is rooted in producing healthy, holistic pet food that promotes a balanced and nutritious diet for dogs.
One of the key features that sets Blue Buffalo apart is its focus on real meat as the primary ingredient in its recipes. The brand also boasts its exclusive LifeSource Bits, a blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that are carefully selected to support a dog’s overall health. These bits are added cold-formed to preserve their potency, ensuring that pets get the maximum nutritional benefit.
Blue Buffalo is positioned as a premium product with a higher price tag. What distinguishes Blue Buffalo is its emphasis on natural ingredients, including high-quality proteins like chicken, lamb, or fish, and the absence of artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors.
Advantages of Blue Buffalo
- High-Quality Ingredients: Real meat is always the first ingredient, along with fruits, vegetables, and whole grains.
- LifeSource Bits: A unique blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals designed to support immune health and balance.
- No Artificial Additives: Blue Buffalo avoids using artificial flavors, preservatives, or by-product meals.
- Grain-Free Options: The brand offers a variety of grain-free formulas, catering to dogs with specific dietary needs or sensitivities.
- Holistic Approach: The brand’s focus on natural, wholesome ingredients promotes overall health and well-being.
Disadvantages of Blue Buffalo
- Higher Price: As a premium brand, Blue Buffalo is more expensive than other brands like Kirkland.
- Potential for Allergens: Some formulas contain common ingredients that may be allergenic to some dogs, such as chicken or grains.
- Recall History: Blue Buffalo has had a few recalls over the years (more on that later).
- May Not Suit All Dogs: Some dogs may not thrive on Blue Buffalo formulas, especially those with specific protein or ingredient sensitivities.
- High-quality, natural ingredients
- Real meat is the primary protein source
- LifeSource Bits for added nutritional benefits
- No artificial preservatives, flavors, or by-products
- Offers grain-free and limited ingredient options
- More expensive than other brands.
- Some formulas contain common allergens
- History of product recalls
- Higher calorie content in some varieties (can lead to weight gain if portions are not monitored)
Blue Buffalo’s Top-Rated Dog Food – Life Protection Formula Chicken and Brown Rice
Blue Buffalo’s Life Protection Formula Healthy Weight Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food is designed to help dogs maintain a healthy weight while still providing essential nutrients. This formula features real chicken as the first ingredient, ensuring a high-quality source of protein for muscle maintenance. It also includes wholesome brown rice and vegetables to deliver fiber for healthy digestion.
One of the standout features of this recipe is its reduced calorie content, making it ideal for dogs prone to weight gain or needing weight management. Blue Buffalo’s exclusive LifeSource Bits, a blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals, support immune health and overall well-being.
The formula is free from artificial flavors, preservatives, and by-product meals, which many pet owners appreciate. However, some dogs with grain sensitivities may not do well with the inclusion of brown rice. Overall, this product is a great option for dog owners seeking a nutritious, weight-conscious formula with natural ingredients to keep their pets healthy and satisfied.
Main Ingredients:
- Deboned Chicken
- Brown Rice
- Oatmeal
- Peas
- Flaxseed
Guaranteed Analysis
- Crude Protein: 24.0% min
- Crude Fat: 14.0% min
- Crude Fiber: 5.0% max
- Moisture: 10.0% max
Nutritional Breakdown
- Carb: 41%
- Fat: 35%
- Protein: 24%
- Calories per cup: 377
More Top Rated Recipes From Blue Buffalo
| Rating | Image | Product | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
Life Protection Formula Adult Beef & Brown Rice |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
|
|
Freedom Complete & Balanced Nutrition |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
|
Wilderness Salmon Recipe Adult High-Protein Grain-Free |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
Life Protection Formula Adult |
|
CHECK PRICE |
About Kirkland Dog Food
Kirkland Dog Food is a private-label brand sold exclusively through Costco, known for offering high-quality products at affordable prices. Produced by Diamond Pet Foods, Kirkland dog food delivers excellent value for pet owners who want nutritious, balanced meals for their dogs without breaking the bank. The brand is known for using quality ingredients, such as real meat as the first ingredient, alongside wholesome grains, vegetables, and fruits. Despite its lower price point, Kirkland offers a range of formulas, including grain-free options, that cater to dogs with various dietary needs and sensitivities.
What sets Kirkland dog food apart from more premium brands like Blue Buffalo is its balance of affordability and quality. While Kirkland is not marketed as a premium product, it still emphasizes high-quality proteins like chicken, lamb, or salmon, and avoids ingredients like corn, soy, and wheat, which are common in many low-cost dog foods. Additionally, Kirkland includes probiotics to support digestive health, as well as added vitamins and minerals to promote overall well-being. Although Kirkland may not offer the specialized, high-end ingredients found in premium brands, it delivers reliable, balanced nutrition at a much lower cost.
Advantages of Kirkland Dog Food
- Affordability: One of the biggest advantages of Kirkland dog food is its cost-effectiveness, providing solid nutrition at a budget-friendly price.
- High-Quality Ingredients: Real meat is the first ingredient in most formulas, alongside beneficial grains, fruits, and vegetables.
- No Fillers: Kirkland avoids the use of common fillers like corn, soy, or wheat, which can be harmful or allergenic to some dogs.
- Probiotics: Many Kirkland formulas include probiotics to support healthy digestion.
- Available at Costco: Easy to find and purchase in bulk for added convenience and cost savings.
Disadvantages of Kirkland Dog Food
- Limited Specialty Options: Unlike premium brands, Kirkland has fewer options for dogs with specialized dietary needs, such as specific food allergies or sensitivities.
- Recalls: Kirkland, like many pet food brands, has had a history of recalls.
- Less Focus on Premium Ingredients: While Kirkland offers quality at a great price, it lacks ultra-premium ingredients or exclusive blends like those found in brands such as Blue Buffalo.
- Availability: Kirkland dog food is only available through Costco (and Amazon at a higher price point), limiting where and how it can be purchased.
- Affordable, high-quality nutrition
- Real meat is the first ingredient
- No corn, soy, or wheat fillers
- Includes probiotics for digestive health
- Convenient bulk purchasing at Costco
- Fewer specialized formulas for dogs with unique dietary needs
- Past recall incidents may concern some pet owners
- Lacks premium ingredients found in higher-end brands
- Only available through Costco and Amazon (at a higher price point)
- Limited options compared to premium brands
Kirkland’s Top-Rated Dog Food – Signature Adult Formula Chicken, Rice, and Vegetable Dog Food
Kirkland Signature Adult Formula Chicken, Rice, and Vegetable Dog Food is a budget-friendly option that delivers solid nutrition for adult dogs. Made with real chicken as the first ingredient, it provides a good source of high-quality protein to support muscle maintenance and overall health. The formula also includes whole grains like brown rice, along with vegetables such as peas and carrots, providing balanced fiber and essential nutrients.
One standout feature of this product is the inclusion of probiotics, which help support healthy digestion, a rarity in dog foods at this price point. It’s free of common fillers like corn, soy, and wheat, making it a decent option for dogs with certain food sensitivities. However, it may not cater to dogs with specific dietary needs or allergies, as it does contain grains and chicken.
Overall, Kirkland’s Signature Adult Formula offers great value for pet owners seeking high-quality, affordable dog food that covers the basic nutritional needs of most adult dogs, without breaking the bank.
Main Ingredients:
- Chicken
- Chicken Meal
- Whole Grain Brown Rice
- Cracked Pearled Barley
- Chicken Fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols)
Guaranteed Analysis
- Crude Protein: 26% Minimum
- Crude Fat: 16% Minimum
- Crude Fiber: 4% Maximum
- Moisture: 10% Maximum
Nutritional Breakdown
- Carb: 47.7%
- Fat: 16%:
- Protein: 26.0%
- Calories per cup: 393 kcals/cup
More Top Rated Recipes From Kirkland
| Rating | Image | Product | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
Signature Nature's Domain Turkey Dog Food |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
|
|
Signature Adult Formula Lamb |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
|
|
Signature Nature's Domain Grain-Free |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
Signature Nature's Domain Beef Meal |
|
CHECK PRICE |
Blue Buffalo Company Recall History
Blue Buffalo has experienced several recalls over the years. One of the most notable recalls occurred in 2010 when Blue Buffalo issued a voluntary recall due to possible excessive levels of vitamin D, which can cause hypercalcemia in dogs. In 2016, there was another recall due to a detection of high moisture resulting in the potential presence of mold in some products. Additionally, in 2017, certain Blue Buffalo canned dog food products were recalled due to possible contamination with aluminum.
Despite these incidents, Blue Buffalo has taken responsibility and made efforts to address these issues promptly. The brand continues to focus on providing high-quality, natural pet food, but it’s essential for pet owners to stay informed about recalls and monitor any updates to ensure their pets’ safety.
Kirkland Company Recall History
Kirkland Dog Food has experienced a few recalls over the years, largely tied to its manufacturer, Diamond Pet Foods. One of the most notable incidents occurred in 2012 when several batches of Kirkland dry dog food were recalled due to potential Salmonella contamination. This recall affected multiple brands produced at the same facility.
In response, Kirkland and Diamond Pet Foods took steps to improve manufacturing standards and quality control. While the brand has not had frequent recalls, pet owners should stay informed and check for any updates on food safety to ensure the well-being of their dogs. Despite these incidents, Kirkland Dog Food continues to be a popular choice due to its affordability and quality ingredients.
Blue Buffalo vs Kirkland: Head-to-Head Comparison
Best Value
- Winner: Kirkland
With half the cost per pound to that of Blue Buffalo, it’s hard to deny that Kirkland is the stand-out for the best price point here. Although the ingredients may not be of the premium grade that Blue Buffalo boasts, the content is surprisingly similar and the nutritional stats are not worlds apart. Kirkland is certainly a viable option for economic savings while continuing to offer solid nutrition.
Blue Buffalo, on the other hand, is a premium brand known for using high-quality, natural ingredients and its exclusive LifeSource Bits, which offer added vitamins and antioxidants. However, this comes at a higher cost, making it less accessible for those on a budget.
For pet owners seeking high-quality, affordable dog food, Kirkland offers better value. However, if you’re willing to invest more for premium ingredients and specialized formulas, Blue Buffalo may be worth the extra expense.
Availability
- Winner: Blue Buffalo
When it comes to availability, Blue Buffalo is more widely accessible than Kirkland. Blue Buffalo can be found in a variety of retail outlets, including major pet stores, supermarkets, and online platforms, making it easy to purchase regardless of where you live.
Kirkland dog food, on the other hand, is sold exclusively at Costco, limiting its availability to Costco members. Although Kirkland is also available through Amazon, you’ll notice a higher price point for this of approximately $10 USD which may be worth considering for those buying Kirkland due to cost.
While Kirkland offers great value, the need for a membership and access to a Costco location may be a drawback for some pet owners. For broader accessibility and convenience, Blue Buffalo is the better option.
Natural Ingredients
- Winner: Blue Buffalo
Blue Buffalo offers higher standards of nutritional value compared to Kirkland. Blue Buffalo’s formulas prioritize real meat as the first ingredient and include their unique LifeSource Bits, which are a blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals designed to support immune health. The brand also offers a wide variety of specialized formulas, including grain-free and limited ingredient options, catering to dogs with specific dietary needs or sensitivities.
Kirkland, while more affordable, also offers decent nutritional value with real meat as the first ingredient and avoids fillers like corn, soy, and wheat. It includes probiotics for digestive health, but its formulas are less specialized compared to Blue Buffalo.
For pet owners looking for premium nutrition with added health benefits, Blue Buffalo offers better nutritional value. However, for those seeking balanced, affordable nutrition, Kirkland remains a solid choice without sacrificing too much in terms of quality.
Eco-Friendliness
- Winner: Blue Buffalo
Blue Buffalo seems to have a stronger focus on sustainability. The brand emphasizes the use of natural, responsibly sourced ingredients and avoids artificial preservatives, flavors, and by-products, which contributes to a cleaner production process. Blue Buffalo also offers grain-free and limited-ingredient options, catering to environmentally-conscious pet owners who prioritize whole, sustainable ingredients.
Kirkland, while offering affordable and nutritionally sound dog food, doesn’t promote sustainability or eco-friendly practices as strongly as Blue Buffalo. Being a private-label brand produced by Diamond Pet Foods, its focus is more on affordability and bulk purchasing through Costco, which may involve more mass production practices.
While neither brand is explicitly focused on sustainability, Blue Buffalo’s emphasis on natural, high-quality ingredients, and its broader product variety, tends to align more with eco-friendly values. Kirkland, though budget-friendly, doesn’t prioritize environmental factors in the same way.
Animal Testing
- Winner: Blue Buffalo
Blue Buffalo certainly has a more transparent stance on animal testing compared to Kirkland. Blue Buffalo publicly states that it does not conduct invasive or harmful testing on animals. The brand collaborates with veterinary experts and conducts feeding trials to ensure the nutritional adequacy of its products without subjecting animals to unnecessary or harmful testing practices. This ethical approach aligns with many pet owners’ values, as they seek out companies that prioritize animal welfare.
Kirkland, being a private-label brand produced by Diamond Pet Foods, does not provide as much information on its animal testing policies. While there are no reports of invasive practices, the lack of transparency makes it difficult for concerned pet owners to assess its stance fully.
For those who prioritize companies with clear policies against harmful animal testing, Blue Buffalo is the better choice. Its commitment to ethical practices provides peace of mind for conscientious pet owners.
Conclusion
It goes without saying that there is a clear winner here (Blue Buffalo, if you haven’t gathered). But that’s not to say Kirkland is not without its merits. Each brand has strengths in different areas and both certainly have a place in the market for different pet owners. Blue Buffalo offers higher nutritional value, eco-friendly practices, transparency on animal testing, and greater availability, making it ideal for pet owners seeking premium quality with a focus on ethical and natural ingredients. However, this comes at a higher price.
On the other hand, Kirkland is more affordable and provides solid, balanced nutrition, resulting in greater bang for your buck, especially for budget-conscious pet owners. While Blue Buffalo wins in terms of overall quality, Kirkland is an excellent choice for those seeking value without sacrificing too much on nutrition.
