Let's Talk
Share this image

Do These Dog Photos Make You as Nervous as They Make Me?

I know they're cute, but I shudder when I see pets posed with young children. As a vet, I've seen too many bad outcomes.

 |  Jul 26th 2013  |   108 Contributions


Editor's note: This article previously ran at Dr. Nancy's blog, Speaking for Spot. We're rerunning it here so Dogster readers can comment. 

Call me an uptight veterinarian or an overanxious mom if you like, but I get a deep-in-the-gut unsettled feeling every time I view a particular type of pet photo that has become all the rage these days, particularly on Facebook. I’ll bet you’ve seen these photos -- the ones in which pets and young children are posed together.

Share this image
Do you get anxious when you see photos like this one? Boy plays with puppy by Shutterstock

Have you seen the one of the newborn baby practically buried under the massive head of the family dog? How about the image of a young child carrying (dangling) a kitty by one leg? And then there is the photo that frightens me the most -- the one in which a youngster is face-to-face with the muzzle of a dog, and the expression on that dog’s face is usually one of confusion or subjugation. When I view these images I cringe, wondering if and when that animal is going to lash out at that young child. I have the desire to shake the photographer while screaming, “Danger, danger!” These photos are as anxiety producing for me as a high-budget suspense movie.

Share this image
Baby and dog by Shutterstock

The sad story of Big Ben

I’d like to tell you about Ben, a patient of mine many years ago who helped set the stage for my “nervous condition.” One or two adults along with two young children typically accompanied this lovely Saint Bernard to his appointments with me. The children were always busy interacting with their dog. At any given moment one might be dragging Ben around the room by his collar. Whenever Ben did manage to lie down, he was treated like a beanbag chair, the two children leaping and falling onto his soft belly. Ben always remained the gentle giant, ridiculously tolerant of the children’s disrespectful behavior. My attempts to tactfully educate the parents about setting limits for their kids failed miserably. They reassured me that their children were simply demonstrating love for Ben who, in return, would never dole out anything but affection.

Share this image
Are you sure your dog is happy to play with a child? White dog and toddler by Shutterstock

I was saddened but not surprised to receive a phone call from the children’s mother asking if I knew of anyone who might be willing to adopt Ben right away, and it needed to be a home without children. It seems that Ben finally snapped, both literally and figuratively. He bit the youngest child in the face, prompting an emergency room visit and extensive reconstructive surgery. The child would be permanently scarred (likely emotionally as well as physically) and the family needed to rehome Ben or have him put to sleep. Given the bite history, a suitable home for Ben could not be found. I remember crying as I set about the task of euthanizing my beautiful and dignified patient.

Respect and safety

When it comes to teaching young children about interacting with animals, I am all about two things: respect and safety. The respect part of the equation translates into a child behaving gently and kindly towards animals -- no tugging on ears or tails, placing fingers inside mouths, pulling on collars, using the animal as a body pillow, lifting the animal without help from a grown-up, or interrupting sleep or meals. Such respect is not intuitive for most youngsters. It is something that must be taught and carefully supervised, no different than when teaching other important life lessons such as the danger of running into the street.

Share this image
It's vital to teach youngsters to have respect for pet animals. Girl kisses dog by Shutterstock

The safety piece is simple. Neither the child nor the animal should sustain injury as a result of their interactions. I would need dozens more fingers and toes to count the number of animals I have treated who have been unintentionally injured, often seriously, by the actions of a young child. Flip the coin and ask seasoned emergency room physicians how many young children they have treated who were injured by the family pet. They too would need more fingers and toes. Be it the child or the animal who is injured, in most cases they are victims of adults not paying attention.

What you can do

Here are some things you can do to enhance safe and respectful interactions between young children and animals. (Feel free to add to my list in the comments.)

Share this image
Playtime is fine, but make sure children know how to be respectful. Baby plays with dog by Shutterstock

  • Actively teach young children how to interact with animals in a gentle, respectful fashion. Role model this behavior every chance you get.
  • Be reminded that every animal is capable of unpredictable behavior. Never leave a young child unsupervised with an animal, even if that animal happens to be the beloved family pet.
  • An eating or sleeping animal is wearing a “do not disturb” sign, which should be respected.
  • If your pet enjoys spending time in a crate or other small, enclosed shelter, consider this to be their sacred space and bar young children from entering.
  • Avoid subjecting your pet to unnatural, uncomfortable poses for the sake of a photo!

Do photos like these make you nervous as well, or do you think I am overreacting? Let me know in the comments.

About the author: Nancy Kay, DVM, is a Diplomate of the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine. She is the author of Speaking for Spot: Be the Advocate Your Dog Needs to Live a Happy, Healthy, Longer Life and Your Dog’s Best Health: A Dozen Reasonable Things to Expect From Your Vet. She writes about dog issues at Speaking for Spot; follow her on Facebook

Read more stories that want your opinion:

Contributions

Tip: Creating a profile and avatar takes just a minute and is a great way to participate in Dogster's community of people who are passionate about dogs.

blog comments powered by Disqus