Get

In Your Inbox

Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

What Is a Backyard Breeder? Important Vet-Verified Facts for Potential Owners

Australian cattle puppies in a cage outdoor

People get their dogs from a myriad of sources, from shelters to breeders to relatives to the nebulous “other” category. That includes backyard breeders. To be fair, many reputable people breed and sell puppies and kittens. They take care of all their pets (including the parents of the puppies and kittens) and endeavor to get them into good homes, all while looking out for the breed’s health. But sadly, that’s not always the case.

So what is a backyard breeder? The term “backyard breeder” carries negative connotations of an individual profiting off of selling animals with minimal investment in their welfare. It could be out of ignorance, as they might not have understood the commitment involved. Other times, it’s blatant. Whatever the case, the puppies and kittens are the victims, along with the unsuspecting buyers who purchase the animals.

divider dog paws 2 oct 2024

What Responsible Breeding Entails

Responsible breeding isn’t just about bringing a pair of dogs together and letting nature take its course. It means understanding the commitment to ensuring healthy offspring. That involves knowing the status of your breeding stock. Some animals, including those with known hereditary and congenital conditions, shouldn’t be bred to avoid passing these genes on to the next generation.

Some risks aren’t evident unless you’re familiar with the dogs’ pedigrees. For example, breeding two dogs with the merle color trait can lead predisposed puppies to a heightened risk of issues with the eyes and ears, from deformities to blindness and deafness. Scientists sometimes refer to these characteristics as piggyback mutations that sometimes accompany a desirable trait like coat color.

Another concern rests with companion animals that shouldn’t be bred for other reasons. While brachycephalic breeds like Pugs are cute, they are born with a condition known as brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome (BOAS) because of their unique anatomy. The British Veterinary Association (BVA) and the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) have policies addressing these issues. Some countries have introduced bans on these breeds as veterinarians believe that good pet ownership practices cannot overcome the anatomical challenges that these breeds inherit.

However, it’s not just about physical problems. Some behavioral issues in dogs may also have a genetic component, such as rage syndrome and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). No one should breed these animals, either. Knowing the background of both parents is imperative.

A backyard breeder may not know about these things without doing DNA tests and other health screenings on their animals. Many individuals working with purebreds will conduct the recommended tests as required by their parent breed club. Sellers should be transparent with this information for prospective buyers.

Beagle puppy dogs standing at home
Image Credit: 5 second Studio, Shutterstock

Postnatal Care

These things only scratch the surface. The other things that may distinguish a responsible and a backyard breeder involve postnatal care of the animals. Young companion animals must be handled to socialize and get them accustomed to sounds and experiences they’ll likely encounter in their forever homes. That takes time and effort, but it’s essential to prevent fearfulness.

Care also requires money. The Companion Animal Parasite Council (CAPC) recommends deworming puppies starting at 2 weeks old and continuing every 2 weeks until the animals are 8 weeks old. Puppies nursed by an infected mother can acquire certain parasites through her milk. A backyard breeder must invest the same care in the parents before they mate to prevent this occurrence. That means these costs can quickly add up.

Dogster divider_v2_NEW_MAY_24_

The Consequences of Backyard Breeders

Reputable sellers often screen prospective buyers. After all, they have a financial and, most likely, an emotional stake in the offspring. They will take measures to ensure they go to good homes with responsible owners. A backyard breeder may not take the same care if their primary motivation is making money. Other consequences of obtaining a pet from a disreputable breed include the following:

  • Pets too young to be separated from their mothers and littermates
  • Heightened risk of behavioral issues, including separation anxiety
  • Increased chances of health problems
  • More necessary veterinary care
  • Higher incidences of stillborn puppies or aborted litters
  • Higher incidences of puppy mortalities
  • Higher incidence of pets bred to anatomical extremes

The latter is an issue with many backyard breeders selling animals that will inevitably have health problems because of their size. Designer dogs are another concern with individuals who breed animals that shouldn’t be bred. There may be a small gene pool of these animals, leading to an increased risk of hereditary and congenital conditions. An uninformed seller may not understand these risks.

puppies in a cage
Image Credit: FannyF, Shutterstock

How to Obtain a Pet Safely

Our first suggestion is undoubtedly common sense. Never buy from a seller who brings a carload of animals to town or an event. These individuals rely on impulse purchases. Getting a pet should never be a snap decision. It requires thoughtful discussion about the household members before embarking on this venture. Responsibility is a two-way street when it comes to breeding and purchasing puppies.

A reputable seller will provide a complete medical history of their animals. Puppies should have received their first series of vaccinations and the necessary deworming treatments. We recommend asking to see the mother and littermates as well. That can give you a decent assessment of the animal’s temperament and health. If the individual refuses, walk away. There’s likely a shady reason for their refusal.

Red flags of backyard breeders to watch for include the following:

  • No medical history
  • No health guarantee
  • Rushed sale pitch
  • Puppies under 8 weeks old for sale
  • Vague information about the parents
  • Unsanitary conditions
  • Puppy parents (especially the mother) appearing unwell, skittish, or unkempt

Reputable breeders will offer a health guarantee for their animals. The timespan varies, but at least 14 days is reasonable for small pets. These individuals will also provide information on the sire and dam in the case of dogs, including testing results for known health conditions in the breed. Again, unwillingness to share this information is a cause for taking your business elsewhere.

We’d be wrong to group all individuals selling companion animals as disreputable backyard breeders. Some people may take this responsibility seriously and take care of the animals. However, the risk exists, warranting extra scrutiny. A reputable seller understands the concerns and won’t back away from questions or requests. They want the best for the animals, too.

With that said, we can’t recommend shelters and rescue groups highly enough. These animals need homes, and you can rest assured they have received veterinary care already. Many organizations have pets already microchipped and spayed-neutered, ready for adoption. You’re unlikely to get an animal with similar care from a backyard breeder. Plus, the cost of adopting is much more affordable than purchasing from a reputable breeder, and a lower price might be why you accidentally reached out to a backyard breeder to begin with.

young nice looking couple wants to adopt beautiful dog at animal shelter
Image By: hedgehog94, Shutterstock

divider dog paws 2 oct 2024

Final Thoughts

People have a soft spot for animals, especially young ones. After all, who can resist those puppy-dog eyes? Sadly, some nefarious people have taken advantage of our collective love of all things cute to profit off of it as backyard breeders. The animals are the ultimate victim of this get-rich-quick scheme. Therefore, it behooves you to consider your purchase carefully. Always ask lots of questions before buying, and if the seller isn’t willing to give you as much information as you need or allow you to visit their facilities, it’s a big red flag that they might be a backyard breeder and should be avoided.


Featured Image By: OlgaOvcharenko, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything dog

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Dogster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

5 Best Electric (Invisible) Fences for Dogs in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Just because you don’t want or can’t have a physical fence in your yard doesn’t mean you need to deal with your dog...

Why Does My Dog’s Breath Stink? 8 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

Dogs generally don’t have pleasant-smelling breaths, but it should not be noticeably foul. It’s normal to smell your dog’s breath when they are...

My Dog Ate Lavender Plant! What Should I Do? (Vet Answer)

Why is it that some dogs just cannot resist the urge to eat things they shouldn’t? A lot of the time, you don’t...

20 Dog Statistics All Pet Lovers Should Know in 2025

Note: This article’s statistics come from third-party sources and do not represent the opinions of this website. Dogs have been people’s favorite pets...

More related

What Were Maltese Bred For? History & Breed Info

The Maltese is a very popular toy breed that has won the affection of many. These small, silky, white companions have wonderful personalities...

5 Best Long-Lasting Dog Chews in 2025: Reviews & Top Picks

It is part of a dog’s instinct to want to chew on things. You might not be a fan of it when they...

Dog Brain vs. Human Brain: Differences & Similarities

Putting dogs and humans in an evolutionary context is vital to appreciating the differences and similarities between their brains. Both share a common...

Why Do Shih Tzus Lick So Much? 12 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

There’s nothing better than coming home after a long day to cuddles and kisses, and that’s exactly what many Shih Tzu owners assume...

Keep reading

What Are Tocopherols in Dog Food? Vet-Verified Nutritional Facts

Commercial dog food is what most owners feed their dogs because it’s convenient, and affordable compared to homemade food, and typically offers all the nutrients that a dog needs to thrive and enjoy a high quality of life. Many different...

dog eating dog food

9 Best Dog Foods in Australia in 2025: Reviews & Top Picks

Dogs are known as “man’s best friend.” As a pet owner, it is important to provide your furry friend with the best diet possible to ensure they live a long and healthy life. Check out our list of the best...

dog eating dog food

Is Flaxseed Good for Dogs? Vet-Verified Benefits, Risks & Tips

Feeding your dog a well-balanced diet that is suitable for their unique needs is important for their overall health and well-being. So, as dog owners, we want to incorporate the healthiest, most nutritious foods in our pet’s diets, so they...

brown flaxseeds

5 Vet-Verified Benefits of Venison in Dog Food: Canine Diet & Health

A vast selection of commercial dog foods are available, including ones with different meats and meat-based ingredients. Dogs are facultative carnivores which means they need meat-based proteins, but can also eat some plants, and like all animals, they benefit most...

venison_Shutterstock_DronG

What Is Meat Meal in Dog Food? Vet-Approved Facts & FAQ

There are many misconceptions about meat meal out there. Since meat meal isn’t whole meat, many dog owners assume that it’s a derivative of meat, similar to by-products. However, this isn’t exactly true. Quality meat meal can actually be a...

dog eating

5 Dog-Friendly Burrito Recipes You Can Make Today (Vet Approved)

Did someone say burrito? Burritos have become a desired cuisine in the U.S., and we’re sure no dog would turn their nose up at the chance for a taste. However, burritos cooked for humans are not particularly friendly for dogs,...

Dog-Friendly Burrito Recipes You Can Make Today

Can Dogs Eat Marshmallows? Vet-Verified Risks & FAQ

Most pet parents love to spoil their furry friends with all kinds of treats, so if you and your family are eating tasty marshmallows, you’ll likely be tempted to give one to your dog. But would that be a good...

Can Dogs Eat Marshmallows

Sunday Scaries FOMO Bones Review 2025: An Expert’s Breakdown

“Sunday scaries” is the feeling of dread so many of us get when we realize the weekend is coming to an end and we have to go to work tomorrow. This feeling likely strikes our dogs too, though the more...

Dogster_SAPR_Sunday Scaries Ft img