Get

In Your Inbox

Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

6 DIY Dog Puzzles to Mentally Stimulate Your Pup (With Pictures)

Dog playing toy puzzle_Lenti Hill_Shutterstock

Playtime with your dog does not need to involve leaving your house. Today, more dog owners are finding safe and creative ways to entertain their pups indoors. Not only can this help you save money on gas, but you can also cut costs on new toys by creating DIY puzzles. Constructing fun DIY puzzles using everyday household supplies and trinkets can be surprisingly rewarding.

Dogs are intelligent, and their canine problem-solving skills will hop into action once you give them interesting puzzles to solve, especially if there are treats involved. If you’re not an avid DIYer, don’t worry, there are several toys that you can make in less than 10 minutes using a few everyday household items. So, here are a few easy DIY puzzles you can use to add to your pup’s toy collection.

divider dog paws 3 oct 2024

The 6 DIY Dog Puzzles

1. The Stuffed Roller Ball

DIY Dog Puzzle
Image Credit: Leopolds-Crate

The stuffed roller ball puzzle is a DIY classic. To get started, you simply need a roller dog toy you can find in your local pet store, though it works best with the JW HOL EE Roller. This soft toy ball comes in various sizes and has stretchy rubber holes that make it easy to fill with your dog’s favorite treats.

You can also tie fleece or rubber strips to the side of the ball to make it more interesting and challenging for the dog. For example, if you have an active pup, you may also want to roll the treats in multiple layers inside the fleece to give the dog an extra workout.


2. Muffin Tin Shell Game

DIY Dog Puzzle
Image Credit: Yes Missy

This classic doggie puzzle is sure to please your pup. To assemble it, take a few tennis balls and set them inside the slots of a muffin tin. You’ll typically need about 8 to 12, depending on the size of the tin. Before placing the balls in the tin, place small treats in a few of the slots.

Next, set the tin in front of your dog and watch them sniff away to find the exact location of the treats. They have to remove the tennis balls to get to the treats beneath. This doggie version of hide-and-seek will keep your dog entertained for several minutes.


3. Toilet Tube Dispensers (with Treats)

Don’t throw your toilet paper tubes away just yet! Instead, use them to give your puppy a bit of entertainment on rainy days. This fun DIY dog puzzle can be made in about 5 minutes. Simply empty your toilet paper rolls and stuff them with your dog’s go-to treat. If you don’t have dog treats, you can add peanut butter or kibble.

The dog will have to make their way to the inside of the tube by licking around it and rolling it around on the floor. If you want the toy to last longer, toss it in the freezer before giving it to your pup. To be on the safe side, discard any pieces of the cardboard to ensure that the dog doesn’t eat any of it as it falls off.


4. Tea Towel Snuffle Mat

DIY Dog Puzzle
Image Credit: Hound Hugger DIY

Here is another classic doggie puzzle that is easy to make and guaranteed to be fun for your pup. You can buy a tea towel online or at your local pet store for around $8. These mats have several pockets, straps, and flaps that dogs love to rip apart and chew on. You can also create your own mat by purchasing a simple plastic mat (such as a rubber sink mat) and punching a few holes in it.

Next, place a few treats inside the mat and roll it up. If you want to get creative, add straps, pockets, and pieces to the mat. Be sure to use sturdy fabrics that are thick and wide enough to avoid choking hazards.

It’s best if the straps are at least 6 to 9 inches long and 2 to 3 inches wide. To make the puzzle, hide a few snacks in the corners of the flaps or the center of the mat. Your dog will surely have a grand time sniffing through the mat to retrieve them.


5. Doggie Ball Pit

DIY Dog Puzzle
Image Credit: Momma Told Me

The ball pit is another puppy classic that helps your dog train their sense of smell. It is especially useful for young pups who are still learning new smells and are curious about their surroundings. To create this puzzle, fill a small kiddie pool or plastic bin with several plastic balls.

Ensure that the balls are at least the size of tennis balls (close to 3 inches in diameter) to avoid choking hazards. Next, be sure to sprinkle your pup’s favorite treats throughout the tub to entice the dog to enter. Then, sit back and watch as your dog dives headfirst into the pit, trying to find the treat while splashing all of the balls around. Not only is this mentally stimulating for the dog, but it’s guaranteed to give them a great workout.


6. Doggie Busy Box

DIY Dog Puzzle
Image Credit: Gone Dog Mad

Also known as a “destruction box,” this DIY doggie puzzle is a classic that will keep your dog entertained and is easy to make. To make the busy box, take a small or medium-sized cardboard box (such as a package box, cereal, or moving box) and fill it with your pup’s go-to toys. They can include play balls, mats, stuffed toys, and anything else lying around their play area.

Next, sprinkle treats throughout the box (particularly on the bottom) and watch as your dog tears it apart, trying to sniff out the location of the treat. There are many ways to make this puzzle more interesting; you can use long boxes or include toys with small pockets and containers to hide treats within (such as yogurt tubs and plastic jars).

divider dog paws 3 oct 2024

Final Thoughts

As you can see, there are quite a few DIY puzzles that you can create to keep your dog amused during the day or at night when they feel a bit restless. Remember, dogs need exercise just as much as humans do. So, if you’re looking for a fun and inexpensive way to help your dog burn off a few of those treats, one of these DIY puzzles can help.


Featured Image Credit: Lenti Hill, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything dog

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Dogster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

How Long Do Police Dogs Live? Average Lifespan, Data & Care Guide

Police officers worldwide rely on canine partners to have their backs and assist in a range of difficult and dangerous tasks. From tracking...

Whippet German Shepherd Mix: Info, Pictures, Care Guide & More

If you’re a dog lover, you’re probably familiar with the German Shepherd, a breed known for intelligence and strong work ethic. On the...

What Are the Dangers of Using Rock Salt Around Pets? (Vet Answer)

If you live somewhere that experiences winter, you are likely familiar with the challenges of keeping driveways, sidewalks, and steps free of ice....

My Dog Ate Gum, What Should I Do? 3 Vet-Approved Steps to Take

If your dog ate gum, your first thought might be that they are going to have an intestinal blockage, but that’s not actually...

More related

Truly Free Cleaning Products Review 2025: An Expert Breakdown

Whether you’re a pet owner or not, cleaning is a daily routine we all have to go through to maintain a decent household....

Foreign Body Ingestion in Dogs: Vet-Reviewed Signs & Treatment

Most owners have experienced the scare of their dogs ingesting something that can cause harm. Canines are curious creatures and will investigate anything...

My Dog Swallowed a Sewing Needle: What to Do Now?

Uh-oh—your dog just got into the garbage and managed to eat a sewing needle. What should you do? Is this considered an emergency?...

How Much Do Beagles Shed? Hair Cycle & Grooming Tips

Beagles may not have lush, fluffy fur, but these dogs still shed. In fact, Beagles shed moderately throughout the year. Where it gets...

Keep reading

Can Dogs Eat Orange Chicken? Vet-Verified Facts & Better Alternatives

Dogs enjoy eating sweet and savory foods, and most won’t refuse a serving of chicken. It may seem like orange chicken is an ideal food for dogs, and dogs can develop a taste for it. However, it’s not recommended to...

Dogster-Can-Dogs-Eat-Orange Chicken

6 Best Foods for German Shepherds to Gain Weight in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

German Shepherds are strong, highly active dogs that require a quality high-protein diet to stay fit and healthy throughout their lives. Without a proper diet, it can be tough for these dogs to keep a healthy weight on. If your...

german shepherd eating dog food outdoors

What Is Chicken Meal in Dog Food and How Safe Is It? Vet-Verified Facts & FAQ

As a dog owner, you want to provide your pet with the best nutrition possible to ensure a long, happy, and healthy life. There are plenty of commercial dog food options available on the market, many of which have unique...

shar pei dog eating

Can Dogs Eat Carrot Cake? Vet-Reviewed Facts & Safe Recipes

We are all well aware that human foods can be harmful to dogs. Some just don’t have any health benefits for canines, while others are highly toxic to them, including many sweet treats. Dogs shouldn’t eat carrot cake, though if...

Can Dogs Eat Carrot Cake

How Long Will Dog Food Last? Vet-Approved Facts & FAQ

This is an important question, particularly if you have multiple dogs or a giant breed or buy in bulk. Of course, how you answer this question also depends on the kind of food that you purchase. First, look at the...

woman feeding dog with dry food

Wellness Dog Food vs Blue Buffalo: Pros, Cons & What to Choose

One of the most frustrating moments as a pet parent is when you’re sitting there scratching your head over which food is better for your dog—especially when every brand claims to be the best! Two popular dog food brands vying...

Dogster_Dog Food Wellness VS Blue Buffalo

5 Safe Chews for Dogs: How to Choose the Right Dog Chews (Vet Approved)

No one would argue that dogs love to chew! It seems to be one of their favorite daily activities. Since it’s something that they do so frequently, you may think that they have an iron stomach and can chew up...

Golden Retriever holding a chew

Taste of the Wild Dog Food Review 2025: Recalls, Pros & Cons

Review Summary Taste of the Wild is a pet food brand owned by Diamond Pet Foods, which has its headquarters in Meta, Missouri. The brand’s mission is to create nutrient-packed, affordable cat and dog food that mimics their wild ancestor’s...

Dogster_Taste of the Wild High Prairie Puppy Food Review