Get

In Your Inbox

Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

I Gave My Dog Away & Regret It: How to Avoid This Mistake

close up portrait of girl hugging dog

Dogs may be man’s best friend, but sometimes, no matter how much we love them, we can’t keep them with us. There may come a time when you give your dog away for some reason, and when rehoming a pet, many emotions can arise. One of the big ones? Regret.

However, you can avoid the mistake of giving your dog away and regretting it. In some cases, you may be able to avoid giving your dog away, while in others, you can learn how to cope with the regret (and other emotions). If you’ve found yourself in a situation where you’re considering giving your pup up and are afraid you’ll regret it, here’s what you should know.

divider dog paws 4 oct 2024

The 4 Reasons for Rehoming a Dog

The first thing to recognize is that, in some instances, giving your dog away is the only thing you can do, and it’s best for everyone involved. So, if you’re thinking of giving your pet to someone else, consider the decision carefully to determine if the reason why is one that will lead to minimal regret on your part or whether you’re doing this more on a whim or bad day. If you’ve already given your dog away, consider it might have been the right thing to do, even if it doesn’t feel like it.

Here are just a few of the very valid reasons a pup might need to be rehomed.

1. Health Issues

If someone in the family develops health issues, having a dog in the home may no longer be viable. It might be that the primary caretaker of the canine has suffered from something serious, such as a stroke, and can no longer properly care for the pup. Or it might be that the dog’s main caretaker now has to also be the caretaker of someone else in the household, which doesn’t leave them the time to also care for the dog. There are even some illnesses where having a dog in the home could make that person sicker. Illness, accident, injury, and the inability to care for a dog are all valid reasons for giving a dog away.

beagle dog sick sad on bed
Image Credit: Iryna Imago, Shutterstock

2. A Risk to Others

If you’ve adopted a dog from a shelter or someplace similar, the shelter may not always know the full history of the animal. And sometimes, that means a dog you adopt who was terrific when you met them and looked great on paper ends up having behavioral issues that make them a risk to others. For example, some people adopt dogs and bring them home only to discover that they are fearful of men, which leads to inappropriate behavior like snapping or even biting when men are around.

Or a pup might be so territorial of their people that they don’t want to let others into the home or try to attack whoever comes to the door. You might even get a dog home only to discover they don’t like being around children and are snappy with them.

If you’ve brought home a pup only to learn that they have behavioral issues, your first step should be to talk with a vet about how to remedy the behavior. However, if you’ve put in the work with the dog to retrain them and reduce the risky behaviors but nothing is changing, rehoming them is the best idea for all. A canine with issues that result in behavior like biting could seriously harm someone, and chances are they’re unhappy, so giving them to someone capable of handling their behavior while keeping others safe is best for all.

If you need to speak with a vet but can't get to one, head over to PangoVet. It's an online service where you can talk to a vet online and get the personalized advice you need for your pet — all at an affordable price!

PangoVet_Mention-in-Content Savings V1


3. The Wrong Fit

Occasionally, a dog is just the wrong fit for you and your family. Maybe you researched dog breeds thoroughly to determine you were getting a pup who fits your lifestyle, only to get the dog home and have them act the exact opposite of how the breed typically acts. Perhaps you ended up with a working dog instead of a lap dog but don’t have a job to give them, so they’re bored or anxious. There are several different ways you could get a wrong fit, and that’s fine. It happens. It’s also another instance when giving a dog away is a good idea, as it will allow both of you to live your best lives.

Pit Bull Terrier mixed breed dog holding its ears back
Image Credit: Mary Swift, Shutterstock

4. Finances

Losing a job can put a dent in your finances, and that can affect your pup. If you’ve found yourself down on your luck and can no longer keep up with vet visits or are having to decide whether to feed yourself or your pet, giving your dog away to someone who can care for them financially is a wise decision.

divider dog paws 4 oct 2024

How to Deal With Regret and Other Emotions

Thinking of giving your pup away for a valid reason but still expecting to experience regret or grief? That’s absolutely normal, but there are ways you can acknowledge and deal with these emotions so they don’t linger. And remember, if you’ve given your dog away because there was no other solution, you didn’t fail them. You just gave them a chance at a happy life with someone else.

  • See if you can stay in touch with the dog’s new family. Some people will be more than willing to send you an occasional update on how the dog is doing in their new home to set your mind at ease.
  • Remind yourself that your former pet is bringing joy to a new family and that you’ve given them an opportunity to live their best life.
  • Remember all the good times you had with your pup.
  • Take care of yourself. You may find yourself experiencing regret, sadness, guilt, and more, so be gentle with yourself. It’s okay to feel these things, but don’t hyperfocus on them. Acknowledge what you’re feeling, share those feelings with others, and do something kind for yourself.
woman lying on bed holding photo in frame and crying or sad looking at picture
Image Credit: Dikushin Dmitry, Shutterstock

divider dog paws 4 oct 2024

Final Thoughts

If you’re considering giving your dog away, you may be afraid you are making a mistake and will feel some regret over the decision after it is done. However, if you’ve given your pet away for a good reason, such as sudden health problems or a change in finances, then you can rest assured you made the right decision, which can help you avoid regret. Making the best decision for you and your pup does not mean you won’t feel any regret or sadness, but if you recognize you gave them up because of circumstances beyond your control and enabled them to continue having a joyous life, you can by-step a lot of the negative emotions that may arise.


Featured Image Credit: gabczi, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything dog

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Dogster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

Can Dogs Get Styes? Vet-Reviewed Signs, Causes & Treatment

If you have ever had a stye, you know just how painful it can be. If your dog is showing eye irritation with...

10 Fascinating Facts About Guide Dogs (Vet-Approved)

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), roughly 12 million people aged 40 years or older in the US live...

Why Does My Dog Bark at His Bone? 4 Likely Reasons

Dogs do many odd things that come off as quite comedic to us humans. One such behavior is the habit that some dogs...

Returning a Dog to the Shelter: Vet-Approved Facts & Guide

It can happen to anyone. A sinking feeling, a disconnect, the realization that the dog you recently adopted from the shelter just isn’t...

More related

How to Get a Puppy to Eat Dry Food: 10 Tips & Tricks

Owning a puppy can be one of the most hilarious, adorable, heartwarming, and frustrating experiences that anyone can have. Taking care of a...

How Much Do Swedish Vallhunds Cost? 2025 Price Guide

The Swedish Vallhund is a delightful little dog that resembles a Corgi due to their tiny legs. These dogs, however, are unconnected. This...

My Dog Ate Nutella: Should I Be Worried? Our Vet Answers

When it comes to food, dogs are notoriously greedy, even desiring their owners’ food. But not all the foods that humans can consume...

Dalmatian Dog Breed: Info, Pictures, Care & More

You’ve probably seen the movie 101 Dalmatians, so you may think you’re pretty familiar with the Dalmatian breed. But how much do you...

Keep reading

How Much Food to Feed a Lab: Feeding Guide & Nutritional Tips

Wouldn’t you love to feed your Labrador dog the best, high-quality food in the exact quantities it needs to thrive? Every dog owner wants this more than anything, yet they can never figure it out. We don’t blame them! Thousands...

labrador retriever eating dog food

Is It Alright if My Dog Only Eats Wet Food? Vet-Approved Facts & FAQ

We all want to ensure that we are feeding our dogs a well-balanced diet that meets all their nutritional needs. Not only are there an overwhelming number of choices for dog food brands and food varieties, but there is a...

dog eating wet food

Canidae Dog Food Review 2025: Recalls, Pros & Cons

Review Summary   Aimed at dogs of all shapes, sizes, and ages, Canidae dog food has been around since 1996 and is one of many high-quality brands available for pets throughout the U.S.A. With its focus on sustainable and regenerative...

Dogster_Canidae Dog Food Review

Can Dogs Eat Acorns? Vet-Verified Facts & Safety Guide

Dogs love exploring their surroundings and trying new things. So, it’s not uncommon for them to become curious about natural snacks like acorns and the nuts of oak trees (Quercus species). But as pet owners, it’s important to understand the...

Can Dogs Eat Acorns

Can Dogs Drink Human Breast Milk? Nutrition & Health Facts

Many pet owners consider their dog to be their baby, and there’s nothing wrong with that. However, there are some things that we shouldn’t be sharing with our pets, and breast milk is one of them. In addition to being...

Can Dogs Drink Human Breast Milk

Can Dogs Eat Thanksgiving Turkey? Vet-Verified Nutrition Guide

As dog owners, we all know how hard it is to say no to pleading puppy dog eyes at the dinner table. But what if your pup is begging for your Thanksgiving turkey? Turkey is a healthy protein so it...

Can Dogs Eat Thanksgiving Turkey

Can Dogs With Pancreatitis Eat Peanut Butter? Our Vet Explains

A big spoonful of peanut butter is delicious and comforting and certainly a much-loved treat for dogs. Unfortunately for pancreatitis patients, it is high in fat and can put a grumpy pancreas into a full-blown temper tantrum. For dogs that...

Can Dogs With Pancreatitis Eat Peanut Butter

Can Dogs Eat Mackerel? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts

Mackerel is a term that applies to various species of swift-moving fish that are mainly part of the Scombridae family. These oily fish are rich in nutrients, provide an excellent source of protein, and are loaded with omega fatty acids.1...

Can Dogs Eat Mackerel