Most dog lovers know about the often horrid conditions of puppy mills, the unregulated breeding facilities owned by disreputable breeders. Dogs are often bred far too frequently, are kept cramped together in squalor, and are not socialized with humans. In addition, these breeders do not always care about the health and strength of the breed, which often results in genetic illnesses, poor health in general and unlikable personality traits. But many of these same dog aficionados, who have t-shirts and bumper stickers denouncing puppy mills, don't know that most puppies sold at pet stores come from there.
There are some pet stores that buy their puppies from commercial kennels regulated by the Department of Agriculture. However, even these pups tend to be unhealthy and unsocialized. This is partly due to the fact that commercial kennels tend to breed many different breeds in one facility and they breed for quantity, not quality. Therefore, their interest does not lie in the healthy promotion of a certain breed but rather in how many sales they can get. So, before you buy that cute puppy in the window, consider the downsides of pet store pups:
10 Reasons Not to Buy Pet Store Puppies
1. Bad Health: Because so many pet store pups come from puppy mills, they are not the result of careful breeding and they are usually not well cared for before coming to the store. Some common illnesses and conditions are neurological problems, eye problems, hip dysplasia, blood disorders and Canine Parvovirus.
2. Behavioral Problems: Because breeding is indiscriminate, behavioral problems are not weeded out generationally. You'll also find that a pet store's staff is not likely to have any training in dealing with behavior issues so the puppies continue to do the wrong things, which become habit.
3. No Socialization: Pet stores pups are often pulled away from their litter at far too young an age, often at only four or five weeks. The earliest a puppy should be separated from his pack is eight weeks and most reputable breeders will say at least 10 weeks. This lack of time socializing with his siblings means that puppy will not develop important canine skills. Likewise, a puppy who has not been handled by people from about three weeks will not naturally socialize well with them.
4. The Downfall of the Standard: In a broad sense, purchasing a puppy from a pet store and then breeding her means you are ruining the standard of that breed because the previous breeders were not concerned with it.
5. Lack of Information: A member of a pet store staff is not an expert on a breed and often not on dogs in general. Purchasing a puppy from a store means you will not get the lowdown on that breed or likely help with any behavioral or other questions.
6. Return at Your Puppy's Peril: Most pet stores do offer a warranty of sorts where you can bring the puppy back if he has problems. They don't tend to tell customers that the puppy's fate, once returned, is usually euthanization.
7. Housebreaking is a Chore: Pet store puppies have spent all their short lives in cages. They do not have the opportunity to develop the natural canine instinct of eliminating away from their food and bed. This causes problems when you try to housebreak them.
8. What You See Isn't Necessarily What You Get: If you see what looks like a Maltese in the window, you may find, as she grows, that there's a little Maltese in there somewhere but mostly she looks like a Terrier. There is no guarantee you will get a purebred dog if that's what you're after.
9. Poor Value: A puppy from a pet store generally costs between $400 and $2,000. This is often more than you'd pay at a reputable breeder who can ensure you get a healthy puppy and provide support afterward.
10. Questionable Pedigree: You're paying for a pedigree, or AKC papers, when you buy a puppy from a pet store but it's very likely that it's not genuine. If the papers are genuine, it still doesn't mean the puppy is a good example of its breed - you need a reputable breeder to prove that.
What are our options other than pet store puppies? Find a reputable breeder or adopt your next dog from the local animal shelter or breed-specific rescues!
Reputable breeders are knowledgeable about the breed they represent and can help with behavioral and physical issues that might come up later. These breeders socialize their puppies early on, breed in good traits and breed out bad ones and they can show you your puppies' parents and give you their history. Human Societies, local animal shelters and breed rescues are all good places to look. True, you don't have the benefit of meeting your pup's parents but rescued puppies are thoroughly examined for any illness or condition, are socialized by staff and trained early on. Also, if you adopt a mixed puppy you will likely find he is very healthy as mutts are often healthier than purebreds.
So the next time you see that adorable puppy in the window, pause and think about the downsides of pet store pups. Buying from such a store is, in essence, supporting them and the horrible practice of puppy mills. And it is also almost a sure bet that you'll have a bad experience.
Related Advice from Other Dog Owners
Help Stop Puppy Mills
Here are three simple things you can do to help stop puppy mills. You may be a responsible breeder wanting to stop puppy mills in their tracks or just a dog lover. Either way, here's how to take action:
1. Stay informed. You can go to things like the ASPCA or the Humane Society of the United States for more info on how to stay up to date on puppy mill news.
2. Spread the word. Tell a friend on how wrong puppy mills are. The more people are aware, the better.
3. Lead by example. If you are getting a dog, be responsible and get your puppy from a rescue or responsible breeder.
~Anna M., owner of Labrador Retriever
What Happens to Those Unsold Pet Store Puppies
I often see people who purchase a pet store puppy because they want to "rescue" it. By doing so, they support a system that allows dogs to live in misery. I realize their hearts are in the right places and they want to save the dog. I also realize that they do not know what happens to the unsold pet shop dogs, so I wanted to tell you about three pet store puppies and what happened to them.
They are a Pug and two Westies, all nine weeks old. The miller breeds for the pet trade and sent them off to the pet store to be sold. When they got there, the store owner discovered all three had physical defects. The Pug had a bum knee and the Westies had hernias.
The pet store owner, not wanting to lose money, called the miller and arranged to send them back. The miller took them back. This is what happens to most unsold puppies in pet stores. Of course, the miller had no use for them. That is where rescue comes in. Many rescues work to develop a relationship with the millers. It is not easy because what they do is a horror to those who rescue dogs, but it helps the animals from death in some situations.
The miller called a friend of mine who works at a rescue and told her what happened. She said that if my friend wanted them, she could have them. No money changed hands and as I type, those puppies are in the vet's office being altered and otherwise fixed up. Once they are better, they will be posted for adoption.
I realize that this is not the fate of every unsold puppy, but it really is typical. So next time a sweet little puppy in the pet store catches your eye, go home and check out breed rescue. Many times, you can find a dog or puppy who was bred under the same conditions that pet store dogs are, but is up to date on shots and vetted. Same quality, better price, vetted and you will not be feeding the cycle of misery.
~Kim P., owner of Pomeranian
A FIrsthand Account
Sadly, if you read my blog (over here), you'll have a first hand account of just how foolish it is to buy a puppy from a pet store. I was pulled in by the cute factor and the 'it needs a home' factor. It was a huge mistake, we had little Jackson for 2 days before I had to have him put to sleep because he had Parvo virus. I'll be off to the SPCA for another dog in future.
~Emma O., owner of a Rhodesian Ridgeback mix
Pet Stores Don't Care About the Animals
About three years ago, my neighbor asked me if I'd be interested in getting a puppy, he knew someone who had to "find a home for a puppy soon." This poor puppy that needed a home came from a pet store that got puppies from a "breeder" who didn't mention that bad knees ran in his genes. The pet store didn't or couldn't sell him and was going to put him down if someone didn't find a home for him within the week. I met this puppy and was told that if I wanted him I could take him home but he'd end up costing me a fortune down the road.
Once they found out I'd love to take him home, they didn't charge me anything but up until they found out about his knees he was selling for around $300. They had him tagged as a "designer breed" since he's a Pomeranian/Shih Tzu mix, but they called it a hybrid and slapped a price tag on him. As soon as they found out he had health issues and couldn't sell him because they offer a "health warranty" they had no interest in his well-being and if it wasn't for a concerned employee, he wouldn't have ever had a chance.
Dante's a great little guy, smart and friendly. He doesn't believe he's a small dog and the vet says his knees don't seem to be giving him much trouble and they certainly aren't slowing him down. I can second Kim's story pet stores and millers don't really have the animals best interests in mind they just want to churn out dogs and make money.
~Kristin E., owner of a Pomeranian Mix
A Note From a Former Pet Store Owner
Reputable pet stores offer a health guarantee on their puppies. It is usually on the premise that you take the puppy to an exam shortly after adoption. Most of these "well puppy exams" are offered free by the vet. If the puppy is then deemed ill, the store will usually take the puppy back. We owned a pet store and suffered many a loss from expensive care provided to an ill animal. The fact is many stores are caring and well managed environments. Make sure you know who you are buying from.
~Tiffany D., owner of Chihuahuas
Not All Pet Stores are Created Equal
I have to beg to differ, like Tiffany. I actually bought my dog, Tater, from a pet store years ago. Tater is now 6 years old and is still doing great. She's healthy, happy and beautiful. I think some pet stores have a reputation that's undeserved. It clearly depends on the management and what breeder they purchase dogs from.
~Nicole, owner of a Pekingese
No Good Breeder Would Sell to Pet stores
I would never purchase a puppy from a pet store, especially when there are puppies who need homes. Pet stores are never sources for well-bred dogs from responsible breeders. Responsible breeders screen homes for their puppies. How would they know where their puppies are going if they are being sold in a store?
I don't buy anything from pet stores that sling puppies. Thankfully none of the pet shops in my area are irresponsible like that. They don't any sell live animals.
Do your research
Ask the pet shops where they get their puppies from.
I got Max, who is 13, from a pet shop when he was 6 months old. He needed hip surgery before his first birthday. The pet shop offered to take dog back, but I got them to refund me and let me keep the dog. The surgery cost twice the amount of the dog, but I'm sure they would have put him down. Twelve years later, he's still doing OK.
~Nancy K, owner of a Poodle