Let’s Talk About Professional and Responsible Dog Breeding


I’m eagerly anticipating the birth of a German Shepherd Dog litter in California. My own GSD, Zoey, passed away last March, and I’ve been patiently (well, maybe not all that patiently!) awaiting a new puppy. The sire to my puppy, Dante, belongs to Deborah Stern, a longtime Shepherd source and mentor. Stern co-owns last year’s Westminster’s Best in Show, Rumor, who recently had a litter of her own, and is now proving she can rock the Mom scene as well as the Show ring!

My puppy’s dam, Rhea, also excels in the Mama arena. Dante and Rhea’s previous litter nicely demonstrates the breed standard for physical and temperamental traits, as well as working abilities. All dogs are individuals, but with such a sound breeding line, I can reasonably expect working aptitudes, health, beauty and a sound temperament in my pup. It’s then my job to bring out her potential!

Dog breeding is a complicated process and also a complicated issue. When picking a purebred dog, do careful research and always purchase a pup from a breeder who will take your dog back if the match does not work out. Beware of buying from irresponsible backyard breeders who overbreed and don’t follow professional breeding guidelines — these breeders are contributing to issues like overpopulation of shelters and, ultimately, the euthanasia of healthy dogs.

So, what exactly happens during the professional, responsible dog breeding process? Let’s look at the basics:

How do responsible breeders mate dogs? Linebreeding, inbreeding and more: 

Rumor and her pups.
Rumor and her pups. Photography courtesy Deborah Stern and Kent Boyles.

True dog breeding takes knowledge, commitment and — in some part — the willingness to take a leap of faith. The goal is to improve a line over the course of generations. Breeders must have a working knowledge of genetics since dog breeding is essentially genetic restriction to a unifying standard. Professional breeders practice:

  • Inbreeding, the mating of rather close relatives
  • Linebreeding, when there’s at least one dog in the generational pedigree of both sides, but further removed (such as a grandfather on one side and a great grandfather on the other)
  • Outcrossing, the mating of non-related lines

Sound complicated? It is. Reputable breeders also invest time in conformation and other sports such as agility, herding, obedience and rally. Titles around a dog’s name evidence his adherence to a breed standard, both physically and mentally. “A German Shepherd Dog, for example, must have a body that moves well in herding,” Stern explains. “When the Westminster Best in Show judge was judging Rumor, he was looking at her nobility and quality, and assessing whether her body moved to conform to her breed’s working purposes.”

Reputable breeders are usually active in breed clubs, dedicated to health studies and research and committed to shaping their dogs into breed ambassadors. Responsible, professional breeders will also take their dogs back so that these pups don’t end up as part of the shelter system.

Puppies from responsible breeders come with real certifications and records.

A French Bulldog pup.
A French Bulldog pup. Photography courtesy Gordon Deen.

Good breeders socialize their puppies, help them transition to new homes and are available to answer questions throughout the lives of their dogs. Conscientious breeders also provide health-screening records for the sire and dam. For example, my puppy’s sire and dam have hips and elbows certified by the OFA (Orthopedic Foundation for Animals). Such records mean my pup’s chances of developing dysplasia are rather slim.

For all these reasons, when it comes to dog breeding, the well-known disclaimer “Do not try this at home!” applies in spades. Then again, maybe we should rephrase the expression to “leave breeding to the professionals,” for many breeders (often the most wonderful ones!) do raise the litters in their homes.

How old does a dog have to be to breed?

A Labrador Retriever pup.
A Labrador Retriever pup. Photography courtesy Anna Wallace, Liberty Run Kennel.

Although some dogs (mainly the smaller breeds) reach sexual maturity as early as 6 months, their full physical maturity takes some time. In general, females should wait until they’ve gone through a few heat cycles before breeding. “Most females are deemed ready around the age of 2, but not before,” Stern says. “Prior to age 2, in many breeds, the bones, ligaments and joints aren’t finished growing.” Furthermore, many health screenings aren’t completed until age 2. The OFA, for example, won’t give their stamp of approval for hip and elbow certification until the dog is 2. “Dogs shouldn’t be bred prior to obtaining their health clearances,” Stern says. “Ideally, a dog is given a few years before breeding to prove themselves, in terms of health, temperament and working ability.”

On the other side of the age equation, females over age 6 generally aren’t bred. In their breeding years, most females can safely have 2 or 3 litters. Males, however, can sire in their more senior years.

When should you spay or neuter?

An Icelandic Sheepdog pup.
An Icelandic Sheepdog pup. Photography courtesy Anna Wallace, Liberty Run Kennel.

So, if we aren’t qualified to breed, should we leave our dogs intact? Now we hit upon controversy. Interestingly, although these surgeries are routine in the US, spaying and neutering in much of Europe and Norway, for example, isn’t routinely performed. However, many of these countries do not have shelter overpopulation issues like the US.

There are medical pros and cons to spaying/neutering. But, unless you are a professional breeder, there are few reasons not to spay or neuter your dog.

Yes, spay and neuter can be costly, but there are options for low-cost or even free spay and neuter clinics or events across the country. With the scores of homeless dogs in shelters, spaying or neutering a dog — even a purebred dog — is the most responsible choice if you’re not a professional breeder.

Read more about dog breeds on Dogster.com:

15 thoughts on “Let’s Talk About Professional and Responsible Dog Breeding”

  1. Pingback: Slip Mating Explained: What is its Success Rate? | PetvBlog

  2. Pingback: Barks.in | Rajapalayam Dog. How to spot a pure Rajapalayam?

  3. I’m doing a project on dog breeding and this website has given me a lot of information thanks

  4. My wife and I have been looking for a new dog for some time now. One of the things we’ve been thinking about doing is going with a breeder. As you said, a good breeder will have records and certifications so that you know you aren’t getting scammed out. Chances are, I’ll probably have to look around a bit to see what my options are.

  5. Thank you for sharing the informative post. I have purchased 8-month puppy and I don’t know about dog breeding. after reading your article I got the knowledge and I decided that I go to a pet shop or veterinary doctor and do checkup my puppy and discuss this topic and breeding safely according to doctor’s advice.

  6. Pingback: The 5 Best Guard Dog Breeds – NEooWS : News from around the world – your way !!!

  7. Pingback: Let’s Talk About Professional and Responsible Dog Breeding | COZY DOGs | Dog Toys, Clothing, Harness, Beds, Health, Smart & More

  8. Pingback: Let’s Talk About Dog Nipples | COZY DOGs | Dog Toys, Clothing, Harness, Beds, Health, Smart & More

  9. another uneducated person in “pretty” as shelters import dogs and now even cats to fill their empty shelters and keep their doors open as a business of selling dogs and cats from unknown sources with unknown temperaments and health issues.. but I must disagree with the author .. please do “try this at home” because without more people willing to be mentored and then breed we will have no dogs . I would guess that none of us are professionals .. breeding dogs is our passion..we study, show, breed and raise great puppies.. but we are not professionals.. there are great pro breeders.. they bred dogs in higher volume ..and under strict USDA and APHIS standards

  10. Oh “Pretty”, how uneducated you are. Most of us DO freeze a quality male’s sperm but (dogs’) eggs can’t be frozen yet. I don’t know where you are but in the US there is such a shortage of rescue dogs we import them.

  11. In today’ s climate of extreme over population there is no such thing as a responsible breeder. If they are so worried that their breed or their specific bloodlines are irreplaceable then freeze some eggs and sperm and wait for the numbers of homeless dogs to decrease.

    They will never do that though because doing so COSTS money while breeding dogs and selling puppies MAKES money. So it seems to be no great secret where the motivation lies… regardless of how many times they tell us it’s “for the betterment of the breed”.

    1. Your response is both ill-informed and uneducated. Responsible breeders make very little to no profit breeding dogs. The percentage that do is extremely small.

      NO-ONE condones the use of puppy mills which is entirely different than a responsible breeder who spends a great deal on health visits for their dogs and pups, giving up their vacations for the love of their breed, and spending thousands on entering shows to raise awareness and in many cases participate in rescue programs.

      You might want to get your facts straight. FYI I don’t breed dogs. I own three wonderful purebred dogs, all different breeds, and one is a rescue.

    2. Where I live (New South Wales, Australia) during the covid lockdowns this year, all the shelters i checked had found homes for so many dogs. Some have no dogs at all. Yay, but when you are committed to finding a rescue dog so as not to contribute to overpopulation and homelessness of dogs, I personally found it a great challenge. Starting in April 2020, I found mainly older dogs with issues that I am not trained or confident to take on. Eventually I ‘bought’ a puppy in July from a home or hobby breeder that is a crossbreed, and a delightful little fellow, but I still check the shelters almost every day for another dog I can give a good home to as well as a little brother. So I hope I did the right thing…

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Dogster in your inbox!

Stay informed! Get tips and exclusive deals.

Current Issue


Follow Us

Shopping Cart