Every once in a while I stop by my local big chain pet store to see what’s new in the dog and cat product world. My neighborhood store has a large area devoted to bulk treats for dogs. No information on the origins of the treats is offered. I often see people feeding their dogs treats straight from the bulk bins. The store allows and even encourages this. I, on the other hand, am appalled. Those people could be unknowingly killing their dogs. I often intervene, but I cringe when I think about how common the practice is.
It’s not as bad as the 2007 melamine scandal yet, but it’s bad: jerky treats are sickening and killing dogs.
I don’t understand why this subject isn’t all over the media and on the forefront of every dog lover’s mind, but for some reason the jerky menace in dogs is little-known and receives scant attention. Hopefully that will be changing soon. I don’t understand why jerky treats haven’t been recalled en masse. Unfortunately that is not likely to happen soon. Of course, I do understand why pet stores don’t have big warning signs above the jerky treats: they’re good revenue generators.
The problem with jerky treats was first formally identified in 2007. Approximately 3,000 dogs and 10 cats are known to have become sick, and almost 600 dogs are known to have died. I can’t even imagine how many more have gone undiagnosed.
Dogs sickened by jerky treats most often suffer from gastrointestinal symptoms such as vomiting and diarrhea, often accompanied by evidence of liver damage. A smaller number of dogs suffer from a form of kidney damage that leads to an unusual and formerly rare (except for in Basenjis) problem called Fanconi Syndrome. In the syndrome a portion of the kidneys called the proximal tubule is damaged. This leads to aberrations in glucose, potassium, and pH. The first symptom is generally increased urination accompanied by increased thirst. Weight loss can occur, leading to emaciation and poor body condition.
Death can occur from uncontrollable gastrointestinal signs, pancreatitis, blood pH problems, or kidney failure. However, most dogs sickened by jerky treats recover if they receive treatment.
Here is the really scary part: nobody knows why jerky treats make dogs sick. The problem was initially considered to be an issue with “Chinese chicken jerky.” However, it is now known that duck, sweet potato, and dried fruit jerkies also can cause illness.
Most of the dogs known to have been sickened by jerky treats consumed products made in China. Therefore, many people recommend not feeding Chinese-made treats. However, remember that China bashing is highly de rigueur in today’s society. It is possible that most of the dogs have been sickened by Chinese treats simply because most treats are made in China. Also remember that many foods that are “made in the USA” contain ingredients that originated in China. Long story short: no jerky, regardless of where it comes from, should be considered safe.
Most people assume that there is some contaminant in the treats that is sickening dogs. However, efforts to identify the contaminant have not been successful. According to a recently released FDA fact sheet, jerky treats that have sickened dogs have been tested for “Salmonella, metals, pesticides, and antibiotics, and were screened for other chemicals and poisonous compounds.” Despite these efforts, the cause of the problems remains unidentified.
This places jerky in a uniquely nefarious group of food and plant items that can sicken or kill pets for reasons unexplained by current science. Other members of the group include grapes, raisins, and lilies (in cats).
The analogy between grapes and jerky may actually be a very good one. There are some people who are beginning to suspect that there is no contaminant. Rather, they suspect that jerky itself, like grapes, may be safe for people yet toxic to some dogs (but not others).
According to this theory, jerky (and not just the Chinese-made variety) has been poisonous all along and the problem simply wasn’t identified until 2007. This is similar to our experience with grapes, which were recommended as healthy treats for dogs until the early 2000s.
The theory is backed up by anecdotal evidence from vets going back 30 years or longer. I have heard stories of dogs dying after eating jerky intended for humans many decades ago.
Despite the theories, jerky illness in dogs remains a complete mystery. However, the FDA appears to be redoubling its efforts to get to the bottom of the matter. It recently sent out a Dear Veterinarian letter requesting that vets help raise awareness of the problem. The letter also offers guidance on collecting diagnostic samples to help determine the source of the problem. Of course, the FDA could simply ban chicken jerky treats, but it has so far refused to do that, supposedly because the adulterant, contaminant, or cause of the problems is unknown. Or maybe someone is paying them off.
Fortunately, as long as strangers, friends, and neighbors don’t give treats to your dog, the problem is easy to avoid. Don’t feed jerky, imported or domestic, marketed for dogs or for humans, commercial or homemade, to your dog. Period.
Most dogs love baby carrots every bit as much as jerky. I recommend them as the best and healthiest treat for dogs. Baby carrots are healthful, delicious, inexpensive, non-messy, low-calorie, and safe. (For now — goodness help us all if it is someday determined that carrots, like grapes, can kill dogs.)
Read more by Dr. Eric Barchas:
- Why Do Some Dogs Keep “Showing Their Lipsticks”?
- Let’s Talk About Dogs and Euthanasia: When Is It Time? Should You Be Present?
- What to Do Before You Get to the Vet in 12 Emergency Dog Situations
- 12 Dog Emergencies That Need Immediate Veterinary Attention
- Just How Dangerous Is It to Falsely Call a Pet a Service Dog?
Got a question for Dr. Barchas? Ask our vet in the comments below and you might be featured in an upcoming column. (Note that if you have an emergency situation, please see your own vet immediately!)
9 thoughts on “Ask a Vet: The Problem with Dogs and Jerky Treats”
I am a hunter and therefore my two GSDs are quite fond of venison. I do all my own processing and they enjoy the benefits of the ofal. I grind and cook then add veggies and rice. I add a couple teaspoons to their Purina Proplan. I also dehydrate venison and use it as a treat. They are three years old now and are in perfect health. They also get cooked chicken, salmon occasionally beef, raw veggies, apples, pineapple and pears. Never any spice or herbs. Have never had an adverse reaction but everything is always in small portion.
Thank you for your great columns. I enjoy and share much of your knowledge.
I love this article. We have been using USA made fried chicken strips with. Single ingredient only. I have 3 different types of dogs. My small 15 lb chihuahua /russell mix has been experiencing constipation issues for a year and we could not find the cause. Recently he started urinating in the house. It was not behavioral related. I took away the chicken strips for 1 week due to my other dog having dental surgery and the constipation was gone and the urinating got better. I think the fact is, these treats are probably fine for some dogs and harmful to others is 100% accurate as my other two dogs seem totally normal after almost 2 years getting the same chicken strip treats. It should absolutely come with a warning and all food/supplements should be discussed with your vet. I’m grateful I discovered this sooner rather then later.0
Dehydrated chicken strips not fried
Pingback: Top Posts of 2013, #10: A Vet Offers a Stunning Theory About the Chinese-Made Dog-Treat Mystery – Orvis News
How about you bash unethical american companies that outsourced commercial pet foods?
“China bashing” is de rigueur because they have little to no ethical standard to go with their phony/deadly ingredients. Talk to anyone at the FDA about how many products from China are on their alert lists. It didn’t come out of the blue to “bash” China — their business practices more than warrant it.
Absolutely! Give credit where credit is due. A few years back remember all the lead found in children's toys from China sent to the US? Among other things, including the China virus! Wake up people, China is not our friend.
What about homemade jerky? Using muscle meat in a dehydrator and then oven blasted for 10 minutes on 300 in the oven once finished dehydrating to kill any pathogens unsafe for human handling?
My Maltese got very sick from jerky treats that we purchased at our local department store. Luckily our vet figured out the problem and over time our little boy got better. But, we’ve been feeding him home made chicken jerky from that point until now. Right this moment actually, since reading this article. Thank you so much for the information. The problem is he is a spoiled little guy and REALLY loves the jerky. I don’t know what to replace the jerky with as we tried baby carrots a few years back and he was not interested at all. We are going to try them again but I doubt he’ll go for it. Besides baby carrots, are there any safe, store bought treats for dogs?