Let's Talk
Share this image

Would "Candy's Law" Solve the Problem of Cops Killing Dogs?

A man forced to kill his own dog after a police shooting backs mandatory police training in nonlethal force when dealing with dogs.

 |  May 5th 2014  |   29 Contributions


The deputy who shot Cole Middleton's dog, Candy, no longer has a job, but that's not enough for Middleton and his family. The Middleton family wants to change the system. Last week, they began advocating for what they call "Candy's Law," which would require all Texas law enforcement officers to take special training on how to deal with aggressive dogs without using lethal force. They would also be required to carry shock-weapons such as Tasers and pepper spray so that their first recourse isn't a gun.

Share this image
Candy Middleton's Grave.

Stories of police gunning down dogs for no discernible reason are always heartbreaking, but the case of Candy Middleton was especially grotesque and horrible. Deputy Jerred Dooley put a bullet through Candy's head when she barked at him, but his shot didn't kill her; Middleton had to drown her in a bucket of water to end her pain because the deputy left after refusing to deliver a second shot.

Share this image
Candy and Cole Middleton

To me, Candy's Law sound like a good start, but it's only a start. The fact that police departments across the country have regularly refused to avail themselves of free training programs by the Humane Society and the ASPCA is a definite problem, but the problem goes deeper than that, into the culture of policing itself. Over the past few decades, public policy has increasingly depicted police as soldiers on the front line of a war. When you're in a war, you don't think of violence as your last resort: It's often the first thing you do.

Dogs and humans are paying the price for that. In January, 18-year-old Keith Vidal, who suffered from schizophrenia, was shot and killed by detective Bryon Vassey in front of his own house after he had been shocked with a Taser and pinned by two other officers. According to the boy's stepfather, Vassey said, "We don't have time for this," before shooting the boy. Even though Vidal weighed only 90 pounds and was restrained by three officers, the North Carolina Police Benevolent Association defended the officer's actions.

Share this image

The problem of police shooting dogs without reason is becoming so prevalent that even the mainstream media can't ignore it any more. On April 29, Inside Edition broadcast a segment about dog shootings. The report claims that a dog is shot every 98 minutes by law enforcement. Despite the number of stories I've written on the subject, I'm inherently skeptical about media statistics without a source. The basic point remains, though: Far too many dogs are being killed by police just because the officers have a badge and a gun and they can get away with it. The Inside Edition report shows video, captured by a 12-year-old on his cell phone, of a police officer who shocked a dog twice with a Taser, then shot her five times. The dog, Chloe, had already been caught by animal control officers using a loop.

Share this image
Screen capture of a policeman shooting Chloe after animal control officers had already restrained her.

Candy and Chloe were not aberrations; neither was Keith Vidal. I could fill the page with similar accounts of humans and dogs. While the training that Candy's Law would give is essential, we also need to stop training police to see anyone who's not a cop as the enemy. We need to return to the idea that you use a gun or a Taser only when you've exhausted all other options.

The Middleton family has a fundraising page and a Facebook page for those who want to support Candy's Law. What do you think about such a law? Would it help? Would it be a start? Would it be useless?

Via Tyler Morning Telegraph, WECT, and Inside Edition.

Learn more about dogs with Dogster:

Contributions

Tip: Creating a profile and avatar takes just a minute and is a great way to participate in Dogster's community of people who are passionate about dogs.

blog comments powered by Disqus