GO!

Do Dogs Really Love Unconditionally?

This is the place for pups to exchange ideas and information about a variety of dog-related topics. Don't furget that there are many great resources on Dogster such as Dogster Answers and Dogster Blogs!

  


Member Since
01/09/2013
 
 
Barked: Fri Jan 25, '13 12:35pm PST 
After some research of why people have dogs, "unconditional love" from the dog is usually first on the list.

I myself thought this to be true, but after some thinking about what unconditional really means, maybe it isn't so true after all.

Would a dog love you if you stopped feeding him? If you stopped playing with him? What if you completely ignore her, you don't spend time with her? Would she love you then? Providing food, spending time - these are all conditions are they not?

This is in no way to demean dogs, I will always have a fondness for dogs. Also, you would be a horrible human being if you decided to do the above. I just wanted to get some opinions!

What do you think? Have you experienced a situation where your dog stopped showing you love because of something you did (or something you didn't do)?

Edited by author Fri Jan 25, '13 12:43pm PST

[notify]
Sandy Baby- ♥

I may look- little, but I'm- ALL dog!
 
 
Barked: Sat Feb 2, '13 2:06am PST 
It's a tricky question. As all dogs are different. Same as humans.

There are actually many instances in which a dog is horribly mistreated, and still shows a bond toward their caretaker who has mistreated him. However, some dogs will grow to fear a person if they mistreat them. May even snap. I think there are a lot of factors in it. It would be impossible to prove without doing some kind of study, I'd imagine. But I'd bet whether or not the caretaker shows them any kind of affection at all plays a large role. For example, perhaps they used to act like they cared about the dog. Showered him in praise, doted on him, made him a pampered pooch. But then once the beginning months/years were over... suddenly lost interest. I think that dog would probably still have some kind of attachment to the owner. Another scenario where I think the dog might would be if the bad owner mistreated the dog, but still occasionally gave him positive attention. Even so, I've heard of some dogs who likely never get positive attention and still seem bonded to their owner. In short, dogs are a mystery.

shrug

I think perhaps other things factor into the equation. Breed, temperament, things of the like. Many pit bulls will usually be people dogs no matter what. But I can't imagine my Sandy putting up with being mistreated.

In the end, it's mostly just personal opinion. It would be hard to prove whether or not they can love unconditionally. Either way, I do know they can love. The idea that only humans are capable of love (which is an emotion, humans only invented the word to explain it) is strange. I feel that most any social species can feel something akin to love. Some call it dependency. Which is funny, because is it not dependency in humans? Unconditional or not, I know dogs do form tight bonds with their owners. Especially when treated right.

Sorry if that came out jumbled. I'm stressed, have a migraine, and it's 5am.
[notify]