GO!

Need help choosing the right dog. Boston Terrier or French Bulldog

If you are wondering what is the right dog for you, this is the place to be. In this introductory forum we talk about topics such as breed vs. mix, size, age, grooming, breeders, shelters, rescues as well as requirements for exercise, space and care. No question is too silly here. This particular forum is for getting and giving helpful, nice advice. It is definitely not a forum for criticizing someone else's opinion, knowledge or advice. This forum is all about tail wagging and learning.

  
Lilee

Wild Child
 
 
Barked: Thu Jan 7, '10 7:58am PST 
I currently have/had a Boston Terrier that my girlfriend has living with her 8 hours away from me. I live by myself and have been looking for a new puppy for a couple of months now. I love Boston Terriers but have also been looking at French Bulldogs. I have had absolutely no health problems with Lilee. I have heard of a lot of health concerns toward French Bulldogs? Could anyone fill me in on this breed. I live in Louisiana. I spend time in my back yard in the summers and would like to get a dog that does not have to stay indoors 100% of the time, that would be able to spend a little time with me outside. Thanks for your suggestions and help!
[notify]
Lilee

Wild Child
 
 
Barked: Mon Jan 11, '10 8:43am PST 
No One?
[notify]
River

"I know I'm- beautiful."
 
 
Barked: Mon Jan 11, '10 2:25pm PST 
I haven't really had any personal experience with the French Bulldog. When I was younger I had a Boston Terrier x Beagle mix. One of of the sweetest dogs, very cute and playful. Here are a few links that may be helpful to you:

http://www.frenchbulldogclub.org/

http://www.frenchbulldo g.com/carefrenchbulldog.htm

http://www.kismet.net/shalyn/health.h tm

http://www.bullmarketfrogs.com/articles/healthconcerns.htm


http://www.bostonterrierclubofamerica.org/

http://www.kismetken nel.com/BThealth.html


http://www.smalldogsparadise.com/small-do g-breeds/boston-terrier-vs-french-bulldog/


From my understanding, French Bulldogs were "toy bulldogs" owned by the wealthy. The Boston Terrier is descended from pit fighting dogs, and is an all American breed.
[notify]

Stinky

*insert fart- noise*
 
 
Barked: Mon Jan 11, '10 6:58pm PST 
Sorry I meant to post on this a few days ago but my phone was acting up. Anyhoo, I have Stinky who is a French Bulldog/ Boston mix. He is definitely the best of both worlds!

Definitely check out both breed clubs. They will tell you any and all health concerns. Going the reputable breeder route will increase your chances of a healthy pup (or older dog).

As for the outdoors in the summer, it really depends on how hot it is. Neither breed can handle extreme hot, or cold for that matter. But if it's decent warm weather and there is shade a frenchie would love to hang out outside with you.
[notify]
Mr. Kite- "Sumo"

being for the- benefit of mr.- kite.
 
 
Barked: Mon Jan 11, '10 9:06pm PST 
if you are going to get a french bulldog, make sure you
go to a responsible breeder. poorly bred frenchies
are likely to have health issues and cost you lots of $ in
the long run. so do your homework first.

they are not cheap. (but worth every penny!)
this is because their breeding is
not easy. usually requiring artificial insemination and
c-sections on top of health testing.

sumo does pretty well in the heat...
but not standing heat, like in the car- i know, never
leave your dog in the car. but i'm talking about- i have
to cool the car in the summer, just like i would warm up
my car in the winter. even with the windows down,
he starts panting as soon as we get in the car, even
on cooler days.

outside, though he seems much more tolerable
of the heat. but they should still be monitored closely-
and don't let them play too rough when it's hot out...
one thing about frenchies is they don't know when to quit!

most CAN'T swim! so don't plop a frenchie in the pool
and expect them to float. haha. they are very top
heavy (muscle heads.) some CAN swim, but i reccomend
having a life vest on hand if you are near a pool or body of water!

i think i will always have french bulldogs...i love sumo.
and contrary to everything i read before i got him-
he is a very quick learner! i use R /clicker training and
it has been amazing!

also, i have seen recommended to not let them
jump on/off furniture or go up/down stairs
until they are a year old- they are also prone to spinal issues.

and they need to be socialized just as much
as any other breed- i know some that are
very aggressive with other dogs. just because they
are cute and funny does not mean they are not still dogs!

they are definitely clowns& fun to have around,
very clever and seem to know what you are thinking.

do lots of research and if you think you can care for a frenchie-
go for it! but like i said, also do your homework on breeders...
if you get a poorly bred frenchie and they end up with
terrible genetic health problems, it will cost you lots of pain
in addition to money.

Edited by author Mon Jan 11, '10 9:08pm PST

[notify]
Fredy

I'm a Good elf
 
 
Barked: Tue Jan 12, '10 12:39am PST 
You'll find a wonderful experienced community here.

Personally we ( our family) would suggest you extensively research the breeds. In any event please do your homework and find a truly reputable breeder. Please Do Not be impulsive (Alas, hold the reins on yourself tightly wink There is a wealth of information available online regarding the two breeds. I can tell you we had the fortunate experience of spending summers with 2 Boston's and they were wonderful dogs, extremely agile and one was more vocal than the other ( both males might i add). Both cute and amusing as they liked to regularly push one another around in a cardboard box for example. Good with children, adults etc.

Health issues that can potentially plague the breeds is an area to focus upon. We suggest you ask for the appropriate Cerfs on these from any reputable breeder. If you do get a Frenchie we'd highly recommend you get them Pet Health Insurance ( like Trupanion for example was recommended by out Vet).

We have the pleasure of owning our first Frenchie. Have had neighbors who owned them and fell in love. ( Although, on ownership - we wonder if it isn't the other way around at times! wink Wonderful pup/pooches and ours has only barked 4X in 2 mos time. She is neither high strung, nor nervous or fearful about anything. She's content to play by herself, lounge in a sunny spot or lay next to a radiator. She loves to snuggle and will crawl up into your arms and fall asleep like a baby ( Really adorable smile Ours doesn't snore particularly loud but has good nasal passages. You should make a note when looking at pups to observe whether they have nostrils clearly open, or closed nostrils (barely discernable slits - Not Good-).
Ours loves to romp in the snow and take a hike, ride in a car, visit horses at the stables, play with other dogs and even our temperamental cat etc, Or stay home and lounge around. She isn't in the least bit phased by rejection and as well greets everyone with warmth and enthusiasm. She is docile with children and the elderly ( took her to a nursing home and she was an angel and sweet as could be with every person she met, leaving doctors, staff and patients with a smile). She was teething and mouthing and we were concerned but when among children and the elderly she's solely nuzzled and licked them. Our pooch is a mush pot. They are said to be of average intelligence and we were able to teach her sit, down and stay in less than an afternoon! She has lots of toys and she has never damaged but a single thing during the teething stage. Potty training has been about average although many say they are slow to learn. Our pup gets it right approximately 80 - 85% and we got her during the winter months. At least when she misses she doesn't choose the rugs. Boston's on the other hand are reportedly easier to train in this department. Some people have frenchies that bark frequently some Not. But in any case they don't bark (sound) like Boston's. If you haven't had the pleasure you might want to check a frenchies bark on You Tube wink LOL - We try not to laugh but it hurts trying not to. Our Frenchie is a comic and really they earn the moniker/crown for "Clown".
Under any circumstance be patient and select a REPUTABLE breeder and preferably one you can travel to and meet with so you can see the sire and dam. Unfortunately, we read of quite a few accounts where online photos of pups purchased long distance either never showed up or the pup arriving at the airport wasn't the one expected ;( Always Interview the breeder carefully and expect them to interview you at length in turn. Take as much time as you need and more. And the breeder should welcome your questions Not rush you along nor skate over anything. You want to see and receive a copy of the pedigree at least 3 generations AKC and a health guarantee for at least the first year. You want to know what health testing has been performed ask for hard copy up front. Also, we were determined to have an American bred pup, as opposed to a European. In our research it seems European's have been a rather serious sticky wicket health wise and this aside from pedigree paperwork that can be unfortunately unreliable to our understanding. i know of several instances where Hungarian bred frenchies it seems well exceed the AKC breed standard here of 24-28lbs. We would suggest you read about the coat color relationship between reported incidence of hearing and sight impairment and make an informed decision that is right and comfortable for you. We personally love the more solid and compact blocky/cobby body of the Frenchie. The Boston's in our experience have been more agile and hyper than the Frenchies we have known. Of course there are exceptions! smile

Our Frenchie hasn't bonded to one person as of yet and so like the Boston has been a family pooch thus far. Both breeds love and need to be with their people, neither likes to be alone but ours doesn't get all frantic, or whine or bark incessantly in our absence. She likes to snooze when we're out.

I could go on and on but here are a couple of sites that may prove to be beneficial. And others here will no doubt share their wealth of experience.

Whatever your decision Both breeds are no doubt wonderful and we wish you a happy, healthy wonderful companion for many years to come!


http://www.smalldogsparadise.com/small-dog-breeds/boston-terri er-vs-french-bulldog/

http://bostonterrierclubofamerica.org/index .htm and

http://www.frenchbulldogz.org

snoopy
[notify]
Fredy

I'm a Good elf
 
 
Barked: Tue Jan 12, '10 9:35am PST 
PS. We should clarify that the seriously sticky wicket we'd mentioned on imports predominantly revolves around Frenchies from Eastern European countries such as Russia, Ukraine, Hungary, Poland, Latvia, and Lithuania. .. and as well during our research issues were raised regarding imports from Argentina. Although, there are no doubt Good and Bad breeders everywhere but lessening our prospects of heartache is something we felt truly important. As there are states with high percentages of puppy mills and back yard breeders in the USA, but then again wonderful breeders in these same states as well.

Also, we would caution you on breeders touting "Rare & Exotic" coat colors and eyes combos commanding higher prices, again please do your homework wink

Some other sites we visited during our exhaustive research, while in pursuit of our pup, which were helpful to us, and as well, made us Very Interested in the parentage/pedigree of our little girl ..


http://agriculture.senate.gov/Hearings/hearings.cfm?hearingi d=1649&witnessId=4758

http://www.frenchbulldogz.org/experts/blog/ 2008/07/08/are-you-the-victim-of-a-french-bulldog-puppy-import-broke r/

http://www.thewrongpuppy.org/

PAWS: http://www.dognews.com/hoffman.html

http://www.zonmiracl.ru/middl emen.htm
[notify]
Mr. Kite- "Sumo"

being for the- benefit of mr.- kite.
 
 
Barked: Tue Jan 12, '10 1:22pm PST 
i agree with fredy- do not go with a breeder who only
breeds for rare coat colors (i know of one in california)
these coat colors are exactly that- RARE...
so if they are only breeding for color, it is
also RARE that they are breeding for health, and soundness
along with that.
and some even in-breed when they have a bitch
or sire throw a rare colored pup, if it's the only
one in the litter- they may breed it back to mom or dad
to "hopefully" get a litter with rare colors.

Edited by author Tue Jan 12, '10 1:22pm PST

[notify]
Bruno

Brunoski
 
 
Barked: Wed Jan 13, '10 10:53am PST 
My mommy wanted a Boston but Dad bought me instead. I agree with the other posters, do your homework on this breed. Dad did it all the wrong way because he didn't know any better, but I have so far been really healthy and everyone just loves me. I'm sure of it.
I am one of the big ones too, I have been up to 42 lbs, but my mom is trying to get me back down to a reasonalbe 37 lbs. (thats a lot for a Frenchie!) My personality is typical Frenchie, I love everyone and they love me back.
It doesn't get too hot here in WY, but mom takes a water spray bottle everywhere in the summer to keep me cool. A life jacket around water is a must. I sink. I know I sink, so at the park I don't go out too far.
I am sometimes agrressive with other boy dogs unless they are bigger than me in which case I bark a lot at them. I'm sure they love it when I do.

I am a barker. A shedder and sometimes I like to barf on the carpet for no reason. I'm not sick, its just what I do sometimes. It took me 8 months, yes 8 months to be potty trained. I do sit and stay and pretty much what they want me to do INSIDE only. I am never allowed off leash except at the dog park that is fenced. No one is going to tell me what to do!!!

My pawrents love me to death and it's a good thing cuz I can be a real pill.
[notify]